Motivation
A surface of revolution is built by turning a plane curve about an axis. The same construction gives a cylinder, sphere, cone away from its tip, and catenoid. Their appearances differ, but one calculation of the fundamental forms describes all of them.
A minimal surface has zero mean curvature at every point, not merely at one selected point. We will find a conserved quantity for a rotational minimal surface and use it to show that, locally away from the axis, the only possibilities are a plane and a catenoid. The proof identifies the precise regularity and rotational hypotheses; it does not classify all minimal surfaces.
A regular parametrization
Definition 2.4.1
(Arc-length profile and rotational patch)
Let be functions on an interval , with
The profile curve is therefore parametrized by arc length in the half-plane . Put
For a coordinate patch take in an open interval of length less than ; its translates cover the whole rotational surface. A profile can self-intersect, so the global map need not be an embedding. Every formula below is local to the regular parametrization. Points on the axis, where this particular angular chart degenerates, are excluded and require separate charts.
Direct differentiation gives
Their cross product has length , so the patch is regular. Choose the normal
It equals . With and shape operator , our convention has . Reversing the normal changes the sign of but not the condition or Gaussian curvature.
Theorem 2.4.2
(Fundamental forms of a rotational patch)
For the parametrization above,
The meridian and parallel directions are principal, with curvatures and . Consequently
Proof
(Differentiate the parametrization twice)
The first form follows from , and . For the second, differentiate again: , , and . Dotting with gives , zero, and respectively.
Because both forms are diagonal, the generalized eigenvalue equations yield the two stated principal curvatures. Differentiating shows that the vector is perpendicular to . In fact , so . Substitution gives without dividing by either or . This formula applies at turning points of the profile as well.
Why the arc-length assumption is useful
The first form now reads : distance along a meridian is exactly the change in , while a full parallel has length . A regular profile in can be reparametrized locally by its arc length. The displayed curvature formulas should not be inserted unchanged when an arbitrary parameter is used; its speed must first be accounted for. The signed normal also needs to be fixed before comparing mean curvature values.
At a profile point with , the formula for remains valid. Such a point occurs at the neck of a catenoid, exactly where trying to use as the profile parameter fails. Arc length passes through this point smoothly and lets one proof cover both sides.
A first integral of the minimal equation
With the chosen normal, is equivalent to
Write . Using , we find
Thus is constant on the connected parameter interval. Conversely, the vanishing of alone need not imply when : for a cylinder is constant and is constant but . We use the conservation law as a consequence of minimality, then verify the resulting solutions directly.
Theorem 2.4.3
(Classification away from the axis)
Let the arc-length profile above be on a connected interval and suppose at every point of the rotational patch. If , its image lies in a horizontal plane. If , after translating the height, its image lies on the catenoid
Conversely, each regular patch of such a catenoid and each horizontal plane patch obtained in this way has .
Proof
(Integrate the conserved quantity)
If , positivity of gives . The speed identity gives , so the image is a piece of a horizontal plane.
Suppose . The minimal equation and give
Combining this with yields . Hence for constants . The same speed identity gives ; substituting the quadratic shows . Since ,
Eliminating gives the displayed catenoid equation. Conversely these functions have , and . Their computed , so . The plane case is immediate from and . This completes both directions without assuming that constant alone suffices.
Proof X-ray
Why conservation is not a converse
Minimality on the whole connected interval is used first: it makes the second factor of vanish, so is constant. The key move is then to combine with the speed identity, which turns a nonlinear equation into the linear statement . The same speed identity is used a second time to fix the integration constant, , so the neck radius is not a free choice. The converse cannot be read off from conservation, because also vanishes when the first factor is zero, as on a cylinder; it is checked by substituting the explicit profiles into the mean-curvature formula.
Geometry of the neck
For a catenoid put . The radius has minimum at . The parallel there is the neck. The meridian curvature and parallel curvature have opposite signs, and , so their average vanishes while
A minimal surface need not be flat: the two principal curvatures can cancel in the mean while their product is strictly negative. A normal reversal swaps both signs and leaves this conclusion unchanged. The formula also shows why a nonzero rotational minimal profile cannot meet the axis within this regular parametrization: .
Curvature and the metric
For these arc-length coordinates the intrinsic metric has the form . The identity depends only on its coefficient , illustrating the earlier intrinsic-curvature theorem in this symmetric setting. It does not say that every arbitrary metric of this form embeds as a surface of revolution with this chosen : the embedding also requires a real function satisfying . Thus is necessary for this particular arc-length profile construction.
The surface area of a parameter rectangle is , because . On a full band it is . This area formula uses and the specified parametrization; if the profile traces the same geometric patch more than once, the integral counts it with multiplicity. The area formula alone does not show that the surface has least area among all surfaces with the same boundary.
A variational check in graph coordinates
The mean-curvature calculation is local. On a segment of a nonplanar minimal profile, , so is a valid local coordinate and the profile can be written as . For a full rotational band over , its area is
Consider a variation with compactly supported in the open interval and small enough to preserve positivity. Differentiating under the integral and integrating by parts, with no endpoint terms, gives
Thus stationarity for all such test functions is equivalent to the bracket vanishing: if a continuous bracket were nonzero at a point, a nonnegative bump supported in a small interval of constant sign would give a nonzero integral. Simplification yields
The catenoid satisfies this equation directly. Conversely, for a positive solution, differentiation shows that is constant; this is the same neck parameter as because for an arc-length parametrization. The first-variation calculation therefore agrees with the conserved quantity found from .
Concept lensStructural
The neck parameter is the first integral of a height-invariant area
In graph coordinates the area integrand does not depend on . For such integrands the Beltrami quantity is constant along every stationary profile, and here
So the conserved found from is the conservation law of vertical translation symmetry: shifting a band in height changes neither its area nor its equation.
This check uses rotational graph variations with fixed endpoints. It proves stationarity within that family, not that the band has least area among all surfaces sharing its boundary. Stationarity is a first-order condition; comparing areas requires further hypotheses and may involve second variation. The graph coordinate also excludes horizontal-plane profiles, for which is constant, even though the original arc-length argument includes them.
Pointwise versus surface-wide vanishing
The equation holds on the whole connected interval in this reasoning. If it holds at one point only, neither the conservation law on the interval nor the classification follows. For instance, a smooth graph can have vanishing mean curvature at one point while bending differently nearby. The distinction between a pointwise calculation and a surface-wide differential equation is essential.
The role of the sign of the conserved quantity
The sign of records whether the chosen orientation of the profile moves upward or downward in height, since . Reversing the profile parameter changes the signs of both derivatives and therefore changes to . The geometric catenoid equation depends only on , so it describes the same unparametrized surface in either direction. The normal induced by the ordered coordinate pair also reverses under such a parameter reversal, which changes both signed principal curvatures but leaves their average zero and their product unchanged.
Checking the normal signs in the examples
One geometric surface admits two unit normals. With the present convention, reversing the normal changes the sign of every coefficient of the second form, so both principal curvatures and their average change sign, while the Gaussian curvature, their product, is unchanged. When mean-curvature formulas from different sources are compared, the conventions for the normal and the shape operator should be checked first, not only the final numbers.
For the cylinder the parametrized normal points toward the axis; for the chosen sphere parameter it points outward. This is not a contradiction: the profiles run in different directions. Whichever side is chosen, the cylinder has nonzero mean curvature, the sphere has positive Gaussian curvature and the catenoid has negative Gaussian curvature.
Worked examples
Worked example 2.4.4
(Cylinder)
Take , . Then , , , and . The conserved-looking quantity is constant, but the cylinder is not minimal. The chosen normal points inward, so the signs of the individual principal curvatures reverse under the outward normal.
Worked example 2.4.5
(Sphere away from the poles)
Take , for . The speed is one and the chosen normal is outward. Here , , and . The poles have and are omitted from this chart, not singular points of the sphere itself.
Worked example 2.4.6
(Catenoid neck)
Let , and . At , , and . Its principal curvatures are and , so but . The profile is regular at the neck even though radius is not a valid local coordinate there.
Worked example 2.4.7
(Cone away from the tip)
Take , for and . Then , , and . The tip is excluded; its lack of regularity cannot be repaired by applying a formula that assumed there.
The cylinder example also tests the converse of the conservation law.
Counterexample mode
A conserved quantity is not the minimal equation
Claim to test: a rotational patch on which is constant is minimal. For the cylinder , , the quantity is constant, yet and give . The identity vanishes here only because , not because . The repaired statement: on an interval where at every point, constant forces and hence ; without that hypothesis minimality must be checked directly, as in the classification proof.
Common mistakes and scope
Common mistake
(Dividing by or using the angular chart on the axis)
Do not cancel from at a turning point, or treat conservation alone as the minimal equation. Do not apply the angular chart at , where .
Common mistake
(Using arc-length formulas with another parameter)
Reparametrizing the profile without preserving unit speed changes the displayed coefficients: and hold only for . A single zero of also does not make a whole patch minimal.
Common mistake
(Zero Gaussian curvature is not zero mean curvature)
Both the cylinder and the cone patch have but nonzero . Conversely, the catenoid has and negative . These examples separate the two curvature conditions without relying on a sketch.
Counterexample mode
A minimal catenoid band need not have least area
Claim to test: since the catenoid is minimal, a catenoid band has least area among surfaces bounded by its two circles. Take and the band , bounded by two horizontal circles of radius . Its area is
whereas the two flat disks spanning the same circles have total area . For the shorter band the comparison reverses: against . The repair: is a first-order condition, and least area needs a separate comparison argument that depends on the proportions of the band.
The classification is for connected regular rotational patches away from the axis and does not prove a classification of arbitrary minimal surfaces or global embeddedness of an arbitrary profile. Ruled surfaces are a separate topic. General area-minimization and stability are not consequences of alone.
Summary
For an arc-length profile, the rotational metric is , and the two principal curvatures are and . The equation forces to be constant. Solving the resulting equation and checking the solutions gives horizontal plane patches and catenoid patches away from the axis.
Exercises
Quick check
(For a cylinder of radius , compute and using the chosen normal.)
Solution · Answer
With , , one has and . Thus and for the chosen inward normal.
Quick check
(On an interval where at every point, show that constant does imply .)
Solution · Answer
Constant gives . Since everywhere on the interval, , that is , so . The hypothesis on is exactly what fails for the cylinder.
Quick check
(For the catenoid profile with neck radius , compute at the neck.)
Solution · Answer
At the neck and , so .
Quick check
(A profile has on an interval. Can it satisfy the unit-speed assumption with real ? Explain.)
Solution · Answer
No: the unit-speed identity would give , impossible for a real function.
Quick check
(A rotational patch has at every point and at one point. What can be concluded on its connected profile interval?)
Solution · Answer
The quantity is constant under the minimal equation. It vanishes at the given point, hence everywhere. Since , throughout, so the image lies in a horizontal plane.