Let be a connected regular embedded surface without boundary. We use the preceding proved local ODE, continuation, exponential-map and Gauss-lemma results, together with finite-dimensional compactness. No global completeness or minimizing theorem is imported.
Motivation
Local normal balls provide shortest paths only near their centers. To connect far endpoints, a minimizing sequence of paths might escape every useful region or approach a missing point. Hopf–Rinow identifies the global condition that rules out this behavior: metric completeness, geodesic completeness and compactness of closed bounded sets are equivalent for these surfaces.
The proof will not extract a limit of arbitrary paths. It chooses a direction from a small compact geodesic sphere and proves that this same geodesic must keep making optimal progress toward the endpoint. A broken path that minimizes cannot turn a corner. This local shortening observation is the mechanism that locks successive optimal steps into one smooth geodesic.
Definitions
Two points can be joined by a piecewise path: the points reachable from a fixed point form an open set, using normal balls, and its complement is open for the same reason. Connectedness therefore makes every point reachable.
Definition 4.5.1
(Intrinsic distance)
For , the intrinsic distance is
It is finite by reachability. The global conditions compared by Hopf–Rinow are the following.
Definition 4.5.2
(Completeness and properness)
Metric completeness means every -Cauchy sequence converges in . Geodesic completeness means every maximal affine geodesic is defined for all real time. A metric space is proper when every closed bounded subset is compact.
Closed and bounded here refer to and the topology of , not to a chosen coordinate image.
Definition 4.5.3
(Minimizing segment)
A unit-speed segment is minimizing if . A constant curve is the minimizing segment when its endpoints coincide.
Theorem/proposition
Theorem 4.5.4
(Intrinsic distance induces the surface topology)
The length infimum defines a metric. For a normal ball as in the preceding chapter and ,
Thus the metric topology equals the original surface topology, and inside the normal ball.
Theorem 4.5.5
(A minimizing broken geodesic has no corner)
If two unit-speed geodesic segments form a length-minimizing broken path, their incoming and outgoing tangent vectors agree at the joining point. Consequently their union is a single affine geodesic.
Theorem 4.5.6
(Hopf–Rinow for connected embedded surfaces)
The following conditions are equivalent: is metrically complete; is geodesically complete; is proper. Under these conditions every two points are joined by a minimizing geodesic. The theorem does not claim uniqueness of that geodesic.
Proof sketch or proof idea
Proof
(The distance is a metric with the surface topology)
Path reversal gives symmetry of . Concatenation and arbitrarily close approximations to the two infima give the triangle inequality. Locally, the preceding radial comparison gives in a normal ball. If lies outside that ball, every joining path must first cross each smaller coordinate sphere, so has length at least every . Thus . These observations prove positivity for distinct points and the displayed equality of small balls. Shrinking a normal ball inside any given surface-open neighborhood proves equality of topologies. The triangle inequality also gives , so distance to a fixed endpoint is continuous.
Proof
(First variation removes a corner)
For the corner assertion, let be the incoming unit tangent and the outgoing one at the join . Use a chart near to vary only a short piece of the broken path, keeping its outer endpoints fixed. Prescribe a continuous piecewise smooth variation field , supported in that chart, with . Such a variation is obtained by adding a small multiple of a bump function times the coordinate components of this tangent vector to the original coordinate path. The speeds remain nonzero for sufficiently small variation parameters.
On either geodesic piece, differentiating length at parameter zero gives , because . The metric product rule and reduce it to endpoint terms. The outer ones vanish, leaving
If , a small positive variation shortens the path, contradicting minimization. If they agree, initial-value uniqueness joins the pieces smoothly. This proves the local shortening tool rather than assuming that a critical path must minimize.
Proof
(Metric completeness implies geodesic completeness)
Suppose first that is complete. Let a maximal geodesic have a finite right endpoint and conserved speed . Its subarc gives
For , the points are Cauchy and converge to some . The same inequality shows as , not merely along the selected sequence. In a chart around , the late position coordinates lie in a compact coordinate ball whose closure is inside the chart domain. On that ball, positive definiteness and compactness give for some . The constant-speed identity yields . Late phase points therefore lie in the image of a compact position-velocity rectangle inside . The proved compact-phase continuation theorem extends the curve through , a contradiction. Zero-speed solutions are constant; left endpoints are handled by reversing time. Metric completeness implies geodesic completeness.
Proof
(Geodesic completeness gives minimizing geodesics)
Now assume geodesic completeness. We construct a minimizing geodesic from to , with . At any center , choose a small normal radius . Its coordinate sphere
is compact. Every path from to crosses it and spends at least before that crossing. The triangle inequality supplies the reverse bound, so continuity of distance on this compact sphere gives the exact identity
In detail, each crossing gives total length at least , hence the same lower bound on the infimum. For each on the sphere, , giving the upper bound. No shortest path to was assumed to establish this formula.
Apply it at . Choose a unit vector with and , and let for all , available by geodesic completeness. The set
is nonempty and closed, so has a largest element . If , use the sphere identity at with a small . Choose a unit-speed radial segment from to of length with .
The initial segment of has length . The triangle inequality gives
so it is minimizing. Similarly . The broken path from through to is therefore minimizing. The no-corner lemma forces its new initial direction to equal . Uniqueness gives , contradicting maximality of . Thus and , so . Its length proves the global minimizing assertion.
Proof X-ray
How one geodesic is forced to reach the endpoint
Geodesic completeness is used exactly once: to define for every . Without it the curve could stop before reaching , as in a punctured plane. Compactness comes from small tangent spheres, not from metric balls, and it yields the sphere identity that selects a direction with exactly the right remaining distance. The key move is to argue at a largest optimal time rather than to iterate small steps, which might accumulate before : the set is closed because distance is continuous, so exists. At the triangle inequality makes the broken path through and minimizing, and only then does the no-corner lemma apply, placing on and contradicting maximality. The argument closes because gives .
Proof
(Properness, and back to metric completeness)
To obtain properness, note first that is continuous on all under geodesic completeness. For any fixed velocity, its trajectory on is covered by finitely many local phase-flow neighborhoods; a finite time subdivision expresses the endpoint map nearby as a composition of the proved local flow maps. Hence it is continuous at that velocity. The minimizing theorem now gives
One inclusion follows from the length of every radial geodesic; the other uses a minimizing geodesic of length at most . The closed tangent ball is compact, so its continuous image is compact. Every closed bounded set is a closed subset of such a ball and is compact.
Finally properness implies metric completeness. A Cauchy sequence is bounded, hence lies in a compact closed ball. It has a convergent subsequence; the Cauchy inequality forces the whole sequence to converge to the same point. This completes all implications without a compactness theorem for families of paths.
Worked examples
Worked example 4.5.7
(A closed graph is complete without solving its geodesics)
If is closed as a subset of , every intrinsic Cauchy sequence is Euclidean Cauchy because . Its Euclidean limit lies in by closedness. Equality of the intrinsic and surface topologies makes this convergence intrinsic too. Thus a connected closed embedded surface without boundary is complete and has minimizing geodesics between all endpoints. The paraboloid is one example; no explicit geodesic formula was needed. Here “closed” means ambiently closed, not necessarily compact.
Worked example 4.5.8
(Distance on a cylinder and two shortest routes)
On a radius- cylinder, let angular displacement be represented by and height displacement by . The explicit complete geodesics from the earlier chapter, together with the minimizing theorem, give
Indeed each integer gives a joining helix, and every constructed minimizing geodesic has one of these angular increments. A nearest angular representative attains the minimum. When , the increments and give two shortest routes. Global existence does not imply uniqueness.
For each initial direction the minimizing times form a closed interval, whose right end is called the cut time.
A natural next question
How long does a geodesic keep minimizing?
For each initial direction the minimizing times form a closed interval, whose right end is called the cut time.
Fix a unit vector at on a complete surface and let . By the first exercise below, if minimizes on , it minimizes on every shorter initial interval; continuity of makes the set of such closed. It is therefore or . On a round sphere of radius , for every ; in a plane every geodesic minimizes for all time.
Worked example 4.5.9
(A relatively closed bounded ball can still be noncompact)
The open half-plane has intrinsic distance equal to Euclidean distance, because straight segments stay in it. The closed metric ball of radius one about contains . This sequence has no limit in and no convergent subsequence there. The ball is closed in and bounded but noncompact, exactly as Hopf–Rinow predicts for this incomplete surface. Ambient closedness of its Euclidean closure would not restore the missing points to .
Common mistakes
The first false statement below is the converse of the final clause of Hopf–Rinow.
Counterexample mode
Minimizers between all pairs do not give completeness
Claim: if every two points of are joined by a minimizing geodesic, then is complete. In the open half-plane , the straight segment between two points stays in , because is convex, and its length equals their Euclidean distance; since , it is minimizing. Yet is -Cauchy, with , and has no limit in . The claim fails. Existence of minimizers is a consequence of the equivalent conditions, not one of them.
Common mistake
(Confusing metric balls with tangent spheres)
A closed metric ball need not be compact before completeness has been proved; compactness in the sphere-selection argument comes from a small finite-dimensional tangent sphere instead. Calling both sets “spheres” must not obscure the source of compactness.
Common mistake
(Exponential spheres are not distance spheres)
The exponential image of a closed tangent ball equals the closed distance ball under completeness. The corresponding equality for spheres is generally false: long geodesics can return closer to their starting point. Also, completeness supplies at least one minimizer, not a unique one or minimization of every geodesic segment.
Common mistake
(Applying the theorem across components)
Connectedness ensures finite distance through piecewise smooth paths. On a disconnected surface the theorem is applied separately to components; the displayed infimum between different components would be infinite rather than a metric value.
Summary
Local normal-ball estimates turn length infima into the surface metric. Metric completeness prevents finite-time geodesic escape. Geodesic completeness permits a small-sphere direction to continue optimally, with the no-corner lemma enforcing one geodesic. Its exponential map then makes closed bounded balls compact; properness in turn makes every Cauchy sequence converge.
Exercises
Quick check
(Prove every subsegment of a minimizing unit-speed geodesic is minimizing.)
Solution
If the segment from time to had distance smaller than , the definition of infimum would supply a piecewise replacement of length strictly less than . Splicing it into the original path would give a path between the original endpoints shorter than its distance, impossible. The replacement need not already attain its own infimum.
Quick check
(Explain why properness requires closed bounded sets. Give a bounded noncompact subset of the complete real line that causes no contradiction.)
Solution
The interval is bounded in but not compact, since has no convergent subsequence within that interval. It is not closed in the complete ambient space. Properness applies to closed subsets; its closure is compact.
Quick check
(Under completeness, prove . Disprove the reverse inclusion using a round sphere.)
Solution
A point at distance has a minimizing geodesic of length , hence is with . On a sphere of radius , every vector of length exponentiates back to , whose distance is zero. The distance sphere of radius is empty since every point is at distance at most . Thus the exponential image of that tangent sphere is , not the distance sphere.
Quick check
(Verify directly that is Cauchy in the half-plane example and identify the finite endpoint of its associated straight geodesic.)
Solution
The distance between two listed points is , so they are Cauchy; their ambient limit has first coordinate zero and is absent. The straight line starting at time zero with velocity reaches the missing boundary at time one and cannot continue as a curve in . This directly matches failure of metric and geodesic completeness.
Quick check
(Show ambient closedness is sufficient but not necessary for completeness. Consider the surface with , , and use arc length along the first two coordinates.)
Solution
Write and . It is smooth and strictly increasing. As , makes . As , the integral diverges negatively because and substitution gives an integral of over an unbounded interval, diverging by its positive integral on every period. Thus is a smooth coordinate onto all . In coordinates the induced metric is , so the surface is isometric to the complete plane. Yet points approach the absent origin, so the embedded surface is not closed. The intrinsic distance along this oscillating surface does not tend to zero merely because ambient points approach one another.