Motivation
At nearby points of a curved surface the tangent planes change direction. The Gauss map packages that change as a map to the unit sphere. Its derivative measures bending in each tangent direction, while its determinant and trace summarize two different aspects of that bending.
Definitions
Shape operator and principal curvatures
Let be an oriented regular surface with unit normal . Since , the derivative is orthogonal to and therefore lies in . This makes the following definition possible.
Definition 3.1.1
(Shape operator and the curvatures it defines)
The shape operator at is . Its eigenvalues are the principal curvatures, and
are the Gaussian curvature and the mean curvature at .
With the sign convention for the second form in the preceding note,
For coordinate vectors this follows by differentiating : . The equality of mixed partials makes self-adjoint. The real spectral theorem therefore gives an orthonormal basis of eigenvectors, so are real and are attained in perpendicular directions.
In coordinates, the matrix of is , where the two symbols denote the matrices of the forms. Consequently
These formulas use the positive Gram determinant of a regular patch. Reversing the normal negates and , but leaves unchanged.
Common mistake
(Comparing signs of mean curvature across conventions)
Some texts define the shape operator as rather than , and the normal of a surface can be chosen in two ways. Either change negates and . A value for the outward sphere here is the same geometry as elsewhere. Fix the normal and the sign of before comparing; only is insensitive to both choices.
Worked examples
Examples
For the outward sphere of radius , , so . Thus , , and . For an outward cylinder the two principal curvatures are and ; hence even though it bends extrinsically. At the origin of , the upward normal gives and , so and . Zero mean curvature at a single point does not say the whole surface is a plane, or even a minimal surface on a neighborhood.
Theorem/proposition
A remarkable intrinsic fact
Theorem 3.1.2
(Theorema egregium)
For a surface, the Gaussian curvature is determined by the first fundamental form and its derivatives. In particular, local isometries preserve .
We state this theorem without proving its coordinate calculation here. It explains why a cylinder can be locally unrolled onto a plane ( for both), while an open patch of a sphere cannot be locally isometric to a plane ( versus ). The equality of Gaussian curvature is necessary, but by itself is not an assertion that an arbitrary pair of metrics is locally isometric.
Area distortion of the Gauss map
Theorem 3.1.3
(Area distortion of the Gauss map)
Suppose . Then the Gauss map is a diffeomorphism from a neighborhood of onto its image in the unit sphere, and its unsigned area ratio is
Proof
(Inverse function theorem and principal vectors)
Since , the derivative is invertible, and the inverse function theorem gives a neighborhood on which the Gauss map is a diffeomorphism onto its image. At a point of that neighborhood choose orthonormal principal vectors . Their images under are and , which are tangent to the unit sphere at because . The image of the unit square spanned by is therefore a rectangle of area .
Concept lensGeometric
Curvature as an area ratio
The theorem describes without a second fundamental form. For regions shrinking to inside the neighborhood where is injective, the area formula below and continuity of give
The sign is read from orientation. Since and , the Gauss map preserves orientation near an elliptic point and reverses it near a hyperbolic point.
For a sufficiently small region on which the Gauss map is one-to-one, change of variables gives . The absolute value is essential for ordinary area. For a non-injective Gauss map the same integral counts image area with multiplicity, rather than necessarily equalling the area of the set .
Counterexample mode
Without nonzero curvature the Gauss map can collapse
Claim: the Gauss map of a regular surface is always a local diffeomorphism onto an open part of the sphere. Take the cylinder with outward normal . The normal does not depend on , so sends every vertical segment to a single point and is not injective on any open set; has rank one, with . Its image is the equator, a set of zero area, which agrees with because . The repaired statement is the theorem above: the hypothesis is what makes invertible.
Example: curvature of a graph
Worked example 3.1.4
(Curvature of a graph)
For with upward unit normal, the fundamental-form calculation gives
Indeed, , while is the Hessian determinant divided by that same positive quantity. At a critical point the denominator is one; away from it the slope must not be omitted. For the paraboloid ,
For the saddle , the same denominator appears and the numerator is . Thus every point of this saddle graph has negative Gaussian curvature. The Hessian determinant has the same sign as for either orientation, but not generally the same magnitude.
Common mistake
(Dropping the slope factor away from a critical point)
It is tempting to read off the Hessian determinant . That is correct only where . For the paraboloid at the Hessian determinant is , but .
Concept lensStructural
One metric, different embeddings
A plane and a cylinder patch can have the same first form, although their normals change differently. The common metric explains why their Gaussian curvatures agree; the distinct derivatives of their normals explain why their mean curvatures can differ. These two viewpoints use different data at the same point.
Curvature constraints on possible maps
A local isometry preserves point by point, not merely its sign. Two round spheres of distinct radii cannot have isometric open patches because their respective curvatures and differ. Nor can the positively curved paraboloid above be locally isometric to a flat plane. These conclusions do not require comparing how the surfaces look in space; they use the intrinsic theorem stated above. Conversely, equal values of at one point give too little information about metrics in a neighborhood. A pointwise equality at one point is not a construction of an isometry.
Example: curvature changes sign on a torus
Worked example 3.1.5
(Curvature changes sign on a torus)
Let and use the standard torus of revolution
The outward unit normal is . Direct differentiation gives and , hence
Similarly , so . The coordinate tangents are perpendicular and nonzero, making them principal directions. Therefore
The denominator of is positive because . Hence is positive on the outer side where , negative on the inner side where , and zero on the two transition circles. The same smooth connected surface therefore contains elliptic, hyperbolic, and parabolic points. Reversing the normal reverses , not . The parameters are periodic, so one uses local restrictions for charts; their seams are not singularities of the torus.
Since , integrating over one parameter period gives
The positive and negative contributions cancel. This signed integral differs from , which counts unsigned Gauss-map area with multiplicity. The equality zero is consistent with the Gauss–Bonnet formula for the torus, whose Euler characteristic is zero; it is not a proof of the global theorem.
Three different invariants
At a fixed point alone does not determine the two principal curvatures: and both give . The pairs give different , namely and . Together and determine the unordered pair as the roots of , once an orientation fixes the sign of . Even then, these two numbers alone do not specify principal directions or the variation of curvature in a neighborhood. Distinguish pointwise invariants from enough information to reconstruct a whole surface.
Quick check
(At a point with and , what are the principal curvatures?)
Use the quadratic whose roots are .
Solution · Answer
They are the roots of , that is , so are and . Check: and .
Mean curvature of a graph
For an upward graph , the preceding form coefficients also give
To verify the first equality, substitute the graph's two form matrices into . For the second, differentiate each component of , where , and collect terms. The denominator is positive, so the equation is equivalent to the numerator vanishing. A smooth surface with at every point is called minimal. The name comes from the first variation of area: zero mean curvature is the local stationary-area equation, not a guarantee of a global area minimum among every surface with the same boundary. We state that variational interpretation without proof here.
Example: a saddle that is not minimal on a neighborhood
Take . Its graph has everywhere, but
Thus while, for example, . The graph is not minimal on a neighborhood of the origin: every such neighborhood contains points with nonzero . Negative Gaussian curvature alone does not force vanishing mean curvature, and vanishing at one point is weaker than vanishing everywhere on an open surface.
A different graph, , has . It too has at the origin without being minimal nearby. These examples are useful checks against identifying the trace and determinant of the shape operator: they constrain different combinations of its eigenvalues.
A local calculation on an ellipsoid
Worked example 3.1.6
(A local calculation on an ellipsoid)
Consider the ellipsoid with positive semiaxes ,
Near it is a graph over the -plane:
Use the outward normal, which points in the positive direction there. At the point itself the first derivatives of vanish. Its Hessian is diagonal with entries and , while the first form in these coordinates is the identity. The principal curvatures at that point are consequently those two entries, and
This computation is local and uses a chart that is regular at the point. When all semiaxes equal , it recovers the outward sphere values and . If , the two tangent directions bend differently even though their product is positive. The calculation also shows how a graph can be used over a coordinate plane other than the usual -plane: the oriented normal must be checked rather than copied from a formula for another choice of dependent coordinate.
Comparing intrinsic and extrinsic information
Consider the map from a cylinder patch to a plane given by . Its derivative preserves the first form because the cylinder metric is . Thus it is a local isometry on any patch where the angular coordinate is one-to-one. Both surfaces have Gaussian curvature zero, as the intrinsic theorem requires. Their second forms differ: the plane has two zero principal curvatures, whereas the cylinder has one zero and one nonzero principal curvature. Consequently mean curvature is not determined by the first form alone.
The local nature matters. A complete cylinder has periodic angular coordinate; a single planar coordinate chart with cannot identify points after a full turn without overlap. Local preservation of lengths is not a claim that the entire cylinder is globally isometric to the whole plane as a one-to-one metric space. Conversely, noticing different mean curvatures does not disprove local isometry, because mean curvature depends on how a surface sits in space.
These comparisons also explain the role of a sign convention. The cylinder's outward mean curvature is negative under , but a different chosen normal changes it to a positive number of the same magnitude. The plane's mean curvature remains zero. The statement that the two values differ survives this orientation choice, as does the fact that both Gaussian curvatures are zero.
A check before applying the formulas
A useful calculation order is to verify that the two parametrization derivatives are independent, choose a normal, and compute both form matrices before taking determinants or traces. At a singular coordinate point the Gram matrix cannot be inverted; one should change charts rather than divide by zero. After calculation, reversing the normal is a quick consistency check: all entries of the second form change sign, so the determinant ratio stays fixed while the trace changes sign. Finally, interpret the result at the point where it was computed. A positive determinant at one point does not establish positive curvature on the whole surface, as the torus example demonstrates.
Exercises
Quick check
(Under a reversal of orientation, what happens to and ?)
Solution · Answer
changes to . On a two-dimensional space , so is unchanged, while the trace changes sign, so becomes .
Quick check
(Can an open sphere patch be flattened onto a plane without stretching?)
Solution · Answer
No. Such a flattening would be a local isometry and would preserve , contrary to . This conclusion uses the stated theorema egregium, not merely the visual appearance of a sphere.
Further practice
Quick check
(For , compute at the origin with upward normal.)
Solution · Answer
At the origin , so the tangent basis is orthonormal and the second-form matrix is . Thus and ; zero mean curvature at that point does not imply the surface is flat.
Quick check
(On the torus above, compare at and .)
Solution · Answer
The formula gives and . The sign change reflects opposite principal-curvature signs on the inner side.