Why unrolling is a theorem
A cylinder bends in three-dimensional space, but a small piece can be laid on a plane without stretching it. A cone has the same local property away from its vertex. A sphere does not. The difference concerns the first fundamental form: it measures the lengths that a person confined to the surface could measure. The way the normal turns in ambient space gives additional information, but it is not the test for stretching.
Earlier notes proved that a regular developable ruled patch has Gaussian curvature zero. That calculation leaves a question: does zero curvature actually produce planar coordinates with the same metric? Here we construct those coordinates. The construction also explains why local flattenings need not fit into one globally defined map.
All surfaces, metrics and maps in this note are smooth. Surfaces have no boundary unless a cut-open patch is explicitly being discussed. Local statements need no completeness, global orientability or embeddedness assumption: a smooth immersion supplies a local surface after restricting its parameter domain. Prerequisites are the first fundamental form, the metric connection, its frame curvature identity, and the inverse function theorem.
The metric test for a local isometry
Let be smooth surfaces with metrics . A smooth map is a local isometry when
The definition already forces to have rank two: if , then (1) gives , hence . The inverse function theorem therefore makes a diffeomorphism between sufficiently small neighborhoods. A global isometry here means a diffeomorphism satisfying (1) everywhere.
In source coordinates and target coordinates , write the matrices of the metrics as and the coordinate map as . Then the exact test is
For an unrolling into the Euclidean plane, is the identity matrix. Matching the coefficients of is often the simplest calculation. A picture of a surface being bent is not a verification of (2).
Theorem 2.6.1
(What a local isometry preserves)
A local isometry preserves the speed and length of every piecewise smooth path, angles between nonzero tangent vectors, unsigned surface area on patches where it is one-to-one, and affinely parametrized geodesics. It preserves Gaussian curvature. A global isometry also preserves intrinsic distances between all pairs of points.
Proof
(From tangent vectors to paths and geodesics)
For a path , the chain rule and (1) give on each smooth piece. Integrating proves length preservation. The same identity for inner products and norms preserves angles. Taking determinants in (2) gives
The change-of-variables theorem proves unsigned area preservation on an injective patch. Without injectivity, integrating the target image as a set may discard multiplicities.
For geodesics, use the fixed-endpoint energy variation already derived in the coordinate-equation note. Around each point of a path, choose neighborhoods on which is a diffeomorphism. Composing any variation there with or its inverse gives the corresponding variation on the other surface. Their energies agree for every variation parameter, because speeds agree. Stationarity is therefore equivalent. The Euler–Lagrange characterization proves that the same parameter is an affine geodesic parameter on both sides. This argument is local along the path and requires no global inverse.
On corresponding charts, (2) makes the first-form coefficients identical, so the previously proved intrinsic curvature formula gives identical . Finally, a global isometry sets up a bijection between all paths joining and all paths joining . Taking the infimum of their equal lengths proves equality of intrinsic distances.
A local isometry need not preserve ambient straight-line distances or the second fundamental form. Nor does preservation of the length of each image path give equality of unrestricted intrinsic distances: the target can have shorter paths that are not images of paths with the prescribed source endpoints.
Zero curvature produces Euclidean coordinates
Theorem 2.6.2
(Local flatness is equivalent to local unrolling)
Every point of a smooth surface has a neighborhood locally isometric to a Euclidean open set if and only if its Gaussian curvature is identically zero. More locally, if on an open neighborhood of , then a smaller neighborhood of has smooth coordinates in which
The necessity follows from curvature preservation. Equality at just one point is insufficient: the hypothesis is zero curvature on a neighborhood. The sufficiency has two stages. First make the orthonormal frame parallel. Then integrate its dual one-forms. A parallel frame supplies directions; the integration supplies positions.
Proof
(Stage one: remove the connection form)
Choose a coordinate rectangle around and give it a local orientation. Gram–Schmidt applied to its coordinate fields gives a smooth positive orthonormal frame . Its connection form is
Write . Flatness gives . Fix and put
Then and
Rotate the frame by , using
The new connection form is . Metric compatibility now gives for every tangent vector . We have constructed a parallel orthonormal frame on without assuming any global orientation.
Proof
(Stage two: integrate the parallel coframe)
Define one-forms and . For smooth tangent fields ,
Here the derivatives of vanish by parallelism. The remaining identity is the torsion-free property. For an immersed surface it follows directly by tangentially projecting ambient derivatives: in coordinates the terms containing mixed partials of the parametrization cancel, and the remaining coefficient derivatives give the bracket . The same calculation proves .
Apply the rectangular integral construction (4) separately to and . It produces smooth functions with and . Set . Every tangent vector decomposes as , so
Consequently is invertible at every point. Restricting to a smaller neighborhood, the inverse function theorem makes a diffeomorphism onto a planar open set, and the last equation is exactly (3). This restriction is essential: local invertibility alone does not prove injectivity on the original rectangle.
Proof X-ray
Directions must still be integrated
The equation allows us to remove rotation from the frame. The separate equations allow us to assign planar positions. They use both parallelism and the torsion-free property. On a small rectangle the explicit integrals work. Around an entire surface, a closed form may have a nonzero integral around a loop, preventing a single-valued position function.
Thus every smooth regular flat ruled patch is locally unrollable, including regular portions of cones and tangent surfaces. This is a local existence theorem. It does not extend a parametrization across a singular edge or promise one planar picture of the whole surface.
How much freedom does an unrolling have?
Theorem 2.6.3
(Uniqueness up to a planar rigid motion)
If are Euclidean coordinate isometries on the same connected open set, then for a constant orthogonal matrix and constant vector . Reflections are allowed unless orientations have been required to agree.
Proof
(A variable rotation cannot remain an isometry of the plane)
The map has orthogonal derivative on the connected planar domain . Write its columns as , . Their orientation sign is constant by continuity, and , where is counterclockwise rotation by a right angle.
Since , there are scalar functions with and . Equality of mixed partials gives
The vectors are independent, so . Thus are constant, and so is . Each component of has zero derivative; connectedness makes it constant. This proves the claim.
The same conclusion applies to two planar local isometries from a connected surface even if neither is globally injective. On each small coordinate neighborhood the proof gives constants . On an overlap these constants agree, because two affine maps that coincide on a nonempty planar open set are identical. They are therefore locally constant choices, and connectedness propagates one pair through the whole domain. We will use this strengthened form to test global constructions.
Worked example: a cone becomes a sector
Worked example 2.6.4
(A cone becomes a sector)
Let , , and use slant distance to parametrize a cone away from its vertex:
The coordinate vectors have squared lengths and inner product zero. Thus . Define
Direct differentiation gives . On any angular interval of length less than , this planar map is injective. A cone patch also needs an angular interval on which is injective. Cutting one generator and taking satisfies both requirements; the planar sector has opening .
The whole punctured cone has no single-valued local isometry into the plane. Indeed, lift a proposed map through to . It and (6) are planar local isometries for the same metric, so by the strengthened rigidity statement they differ by one fixed planar rigid motion. But the proposed map must be periodic under , whereas (6) rotates its nonzero position vector by . Since , these are different vectors. The contradiction concerns the whole cone, not its cut-open patches.
The vertex was excluded throughout: at , so this parametrization does not supply a regular surface there.
Worked example: explicitly unrolling a tangent developable
Worked example 2.6.5
(Unrolling a tangent developable)
Let be a smooth unit-speed space curve with curvature on an interval. Write its Frenet fields as . Its tangent surface is
Because and , it is regular for and has metric
Its torsion does not appear in this first form. To build a flattening, set and choose a plane curve with
Such a is obtained by integrating these two functions. With , define
Then , , and the metric of is exactly (7). Its Jacobian is , which is nonzero. Around each parameter point with , restrict until both and are injective. The map is the desired planar isometry. This explicitly solves the unrolling problem; flatness alone would only give existence.
When is constant, one may take . Its derivative is precisely the defined above. Then . Fixed nonzero traces a circle locally, while fixed traces a straight line. Hence the rulings are geodesics, whereas these fixed- curves are not. The singular edge remains outside the construction.
Worked example: a cylinder has a translation obstruction
Worked example 2.6.6
(A cylinder has a translation obstruction)
A radius- cylinder has metric , so gives local unrolling coordinates. The angular coordinate is not globally single-valued. Nevertheless the one-form is global, since two local angle choices differ by a constant multiple of . Together with it is the dual coframe of a global parallel orthonormal frame: on each unrolled patch these are the constant Euclidean directions.
Around a horizontal circle ,
Thus cannot be for a globally defined real function : an exact form integrates to zero around a loop. More strongly, no global planar local isometry exists. Its differential coframe would, by the local rigidity result, be one constant orthogonal combination of . Its two loop integrals would then be the nonzero vector , whereas globally defined coordinate differentials must have zero loop integrals.
The precise period test, and what it still does not prove
Theorem 2.6.7
(Global coordinates as functions versus a global chart)
Let be a connected smooth flat surface with a global parallel orthonormal frame, and let be its dual coframe. There exists a global planar local isometry if and only if both one-forms have zero integral around every piecewise smooth loop. Even when it exists, need not be injective.
Proof
(Path independence gives functions; injectivity is a further condition)
The coframe is closed by (5). If both periods vanish, fix a base point and define , . A connected smooth surface is piecewise smoothly path connected: the points reachable from form an open set, and its complement is also open by coordinate-ball paths. Two paths to the same endpoint give a loop after reversing one, so their integrals agree. On a small rectangle these path integrals differ from the local primitives only by constants. Thus are smooth with , , and is a local isometry.
Conversely, compare a proposed on each small patch with the Euclidean coordinates constructed from . Local rigidity says that for a locally constant orthogonal matrix. Since the frame and are global and is connected, the same works everywhere. Integrating around any loop gives , and invertibility of makes both periods zero. Nothing in this argument compares two different points of , so it supplies no injectivity conclusion.
For a concrete failure of injectivity, give the parameter plane the pullback metric of the regular immersion
Here , and the globally defined functions , satisfy . Their dual frame is parallel, because in local coordinates it is the constant coordinate frame. Both forms are exact, so all periods vanish. Yet identifies with . By strengthened rigidity every other planar local isometry is and has the same failure. The domain is simply connected, but these incomplete pullback metrics do not turn that fact into injectivity.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Zero curvature at one point is not local flatness)
Zero curvature at one point does not give a flat neighborhood. For example, the graph has at the origin and positive curvature where ; its graph formula has numerator . Every neighborhood of the origin contains such points, so it cannot be isometric to a planar open set.
Common mistake
(Flat, minimal and ruled are different conditions)
A flat surface need not have zero mean curvature: the cylinder has one zero and one nonzero principal curvature. A regular ruled surface need not be flat: the earlier ruled calculation gives , where , so a nonzero mixed term prevents unrolling. In that formula is a triple-product abbreviation, not the torsion of the curve in the tangent-surface example.
Common mistake
(Local unrollings need not glue into one planar map)
Three global questions must be answered separately: can local parallel frames be glued, do their dual forms have zero periods, and is the resulting planar map one-to-one? The cone, cylinder and exponential pullback example expose these successive obstructions. The local flatness theorem answers a neighborhood question and does not classify complete flat surfaces.
Exercises
Quick check
(For the cone metric , test , where . Which constants make it a local isometry?)
Solution · Answer
Its pullback metric is . Equation (2) therefore requires and . Both signs give local isometries; they differ by a reflection. Restrict the angular interval to obtain injectivity. No choice removes the whole-cone periodicity obstruction when .
Quick check
(Let map to on a cylinder. Compare the source and target intrinsic distances between the points corresponding to and .)
Solution · Answer
Since , the source distance is . The shorter horizontal target arc has length . To prove it is shortest, lift the angular coordinate continuously along any competing path, starting with angle zero. Its ending angle is for an integer . The path length is at least times the absolute total angular change, hence at least . The infimum is attained by the shorter arc. Each path keeps its length under ; shorter target paths lift to different source endpoints.
Quick check
(Two smooth unit-speed curves have the same positive curvature function on the same interval but different torsions. Prove that corresponding regular portions of their tangent developables are locally isometric. Must their second forms agree?)
Solution · Answer
Both first forms are (7), because and no derivative of was used. The parameter correspondence is therefore an isometry after restricting both immersions to patches. Their second forms need not agree. Taking a plane circle and a spatial helix of the same curvature makes this explicit. The plane tangent surface lies in a plane, so its second form is zero. For the spatial curve, . With , its coefficient is , which is nonzero for a helix with . Here denotes Frenet torsion.
Quick check
(On a product of intervals consider with smooth. Use the earlier formula to characterize flatness and construct local Euclidean coordinates.)
Solution · Answer
Flatness is equivalent to , hence on the interval. If , positivity gives , and works. If , set
Its radial derivative has magnitude one, its angular derivative has magnitude , and they are orthogonal, so . Restrict the interval to length less than to make it injective. For comparison gives and cannot have Euclidean unrolling coordinates.
Quick check
(A sphere has metric away from its poles. Why does the fact that this matrix is diagonal not imply local unrollability? What changes if all lengths are multiplied by a constant ?)
Solution · Answer
A diagonal metric says only that these coordinate directions are orthogonal. With and , the warped-metric formula gives . Curvature is nonzero, so a local isometry into the plane is impossible. Multiplying all lengths by multiplies the metric by and gives the radius- sphere metric, whose curvature is , still nonzero. A change of coordinates leaves the metric itself unchanged; a rescaling of lengths changes it.