Motivation
A straight line can lie on a curved surface. Move such a line through space and it sweeps out a ruled surface: cylinders, cones, tangent surfaces of curves and helicoids all arise this way. They do not all have the same intrinsic geometry. In particular, the helicoid has negative Gaussian curvature, whereas an ordinary cylinder has zero Gaussian curvature.
The shape of the moving line gives a direct explanation. Along any one ruling the second fundamental form vanishes in the ruling direction, but a mixed term can remain. That mixed term is exactly the obstruction to the tangent plane staying fixed as we move along the line. Computing it also exposes where the proposed parametrization ceases to be regular, such as the vertex of a cone or the edge of a tangent surface.
We work locally in Euclidean three-space. A regular parametrization is an immersion; it need not be globally one-to-one. When necessary, a sufficiently small regular neighborhood gives a surface patch. We will explicitly define the local developability condition used here, without claiming a global unrolling or a classification of all complete ruled surfaces.
Definitions and conventions
Definition 5.1.1
(Ruled parametrization, rulings and regularity)
Let be open intervals. Take maps and with , and consider
For each fixed , changing traces an open segment of a straight line, called a ruling. The parametrization is regular at when .
The choice of is not unique: sliding along a ruling changes its position but not the underlying family of lines. Unit length is a convenient normalization of the direction; it is a local choice and does not assert that all parametrizations in applications are already normalized.
Definition 5.1.2
(Developability along a ruling)
On a connected regular segment of one ruling, the surface is developable along that segment if its tangent plane is independent of . A regular patch is developable if this holds for every ruling segment in the patch.
This is a local tangent-plane definition. In the present setting it will be equivalent to ; a global isometric flattening may require additional work and hypotheses.
Write the scalar triple product as . The Gaussian curvature is , where and are the standard first and second fundamental form coefficients for a chosen unit normal. Reversing the normal changes the signs of but not .
Theorem 5.1.3
(Regularity and curvature of a ruled patch)
Set and . A point is regular exactly when is nonzero. At every regular point,
For a connected regular segment of a fixed ruling, vanishes at one point if and only if it vanishes everywhere on that segment, if and only if its tangent plane is constant along that segment.
Proof of the curvature formula
Proof
(The straight ruling kills one coefficient)
Differentiate: and . Thus is the tangent cross product. With , the first fundamental form satisfies
The second derivatives are , and . Hence . The mixed coefficient is
The term containing vanishes because a scalar triple product with repeated is zero. Substituting into gives the formula. It is not necessary to compute : removes it from the numerator.
Proof X-ray
What the curvature computation really uses
Only two facts enter. Straightness of the rulings gives , hence , so the numerator collapses to whatever is; this is the whole reason that . The mixed coefficient is a triple product in which the -dependent term vanishes, so depends on alone.
Regularity is used to divide by and define ; the formula says nothing at a point with . The unit length of is never used in this computation, so the same formula holds for any direction field. The graph in the practice questions, with the non-unit direction , confirms this. A zero normal curvature in the ruling direction therefore never forces flatness by itself: a nonzero makes the determinant negative.
Tangent planes along one ruling
Proof
(Tangent planes along a ruling are constant exactly when the triple product vanishes)
For fixed , set and , so . Both vectors are perpendicular to . The tangent plane at a regular point is the plane perpendicular to . If , this plane is clearly constant. Otherwise, and are parallel exactly when are linearly dependent, equivalently . To see this, project to the plane perpendicular to . There, crossing with is an invertible quarter-turn; it sends the projections of and to and . The two images are dependent precisely when those projections are dependent.
If , stays on one fixed line and is nonzero on the given regular segment, so its perpendicular direction plane is constant. Points on the ruling differ by multiples of , which lies in that direction plane; hence their affine tangent planes coincide, not merely their parallel directions. If , and are independent; the normals at two distinct values of are not parallel, and the tangent planes differ. The curvature formula shows that is also exactly at any regular point of the ruling.
Proof X-ray
Check the whole ruling, not just one formula value
The argument turns on one asymmetry: for fixed the scalar does not depend on , while regularity does. One regular zero-curvature point therefore gives , and the tangent plane is then the same at every other regular point of the same segment. The quarter-turn step is where is used: it converts parallelism of normals into linear dependence of . Affine coincidence, not just parallel planes, needs the further observation that lies in the common plane. A singular point with can still interrupt the segment, and no assertion is made there, because this parametrization defines no tangent plane at such a point.
Locating possible singular points
The unit condition implies . If at a given , does not depend on : the entire parametrized ruling is regular when , and entirely singular otherwise. This pointwise observation alone does not say is constant for nearby .
Suppose and define
Theorem 5.1.4
(The regularity square on a nonparallel ruling)
If , the following identity holds for every :
Proof
(Resolve in an orthonormal frame)
Put and . Because and , the vectors are orthonormal. Only the part of perpendicular to contributes to the cross product with , and in that plane
since . Crossing with is a norm-preserving quarter-turn in this plane, so . Finally .
Consequently, if the entire ruling is regular wherever it is defined. If , the only possible singular parameter is ; it is actually present only if it lies in . This formula locates a parametrization singularity. It does not by itself prove that the geometric image has a cusp, nor that self-intersections cannot occur elsewhere.
Concept lensGeometric
Curvature along a ruling measured from its central point
When , put , the distribution parameter of the ruling. The regularity square turns the curvature formula into
Along a nonflat ruling, is therefore largest, equal to , at the central point , and it decays like in both directions. Both and the position of that point are independent of the directrix. The helicoid has and .
A change of directrix
For a function , replace by and use , so the same point is . The new triple product is
Thus the flat-versus-negative distinction is independent of where the directrix is chosen on each ruling. The parameter at which a singularity may occur changes by the corresponding shift. This invariance is useful when a chosen directrix makes a calculation needlessly complicated.
Worked examples
Worked example 5.1.5
(A circular cylinder)
Let and . Then and . The parametrization is regular everywhere, and . The tangent plane is the same all along a vertical ruling. If ranges over more than one full period, distinct parameter values repeat the same point.
Worked example 5.1.6
(A cone and its missing vertex)
Let and . Here and , while . Thus the parametrization is regular exactly for , and there. At every ruling meets at the origin and the parametrization is singular. The regular formula does not assign a tangent plane or curvature to that parameter.
Worked example 5.1.7
(A tangent surface)
Let be a unit-speed curve with curvature , unit tangent and principal normal . Put . Then and , so . For the patch is regular, and because ; hence . At it is singular. For the unit circle, all tangent lines lie in its plane. The parametrization still fails at ; identifying the local image there requires a separate analysis.
Worked example 5.1.8
(A helicoid is ruled but not flat)
Take and with . Then , so , and gives . Every parameter point is regular and
The straight rulings do not make the surface developable under our definition. For fixed , the tangent plane varies along the ruling. The parameter controls the vertical motion of the directrix and cannot be set to zero in this example without changing the regularity statement.
Two different ruling families
The graph has parametrization . Fixing and varying gives a straight line, but so does fixing and varying . The two families intersect at each point and have distinct tangent directions there. The practice question on this graph shows that it has strictly negative everywhere. Thus even two straight lines through each point do not force a flat tangent plane along either family.
The direction in the first family is not unit. On any interval it can be normalized by dividing by and rescaling the line parameter. Direct computation with the given parametrization is often shorter, provided its own metric determinant is used.
Common mistakes
Counterexample mode
Zero curvature does not repair a singular parameter
For the cone above, at every regular point, that is, for . Substituting into a simplified expression for zero curvature would ignore the vanishing metric determinant . The formula for requires a regular surface patch; at the vertex this parametrization has rank less than two.
Two further errors concern what a straight line on a surface does and does not tell us.
Common mistake
(A ruling is asymptotic, not necessarily principal)
Along a ruling the normal curvature is zero because , so the ruling direction is asymptotic. It need not be a principal direction. On the helicoid, , , and , so the shape operator sends to . Since , is not an eigenvector. The vanishing of one second-form coefficient also never implies .
Common mistake
(A regular parametrization need not be injective)
A nonzero cross product is a local condition. The cylinder with is regular everywhere, yet and give the same point. Tangent-plane constancy is likewise a local condition along the given ruling family; statements about cutting, globally flattening, completing or uniquely classifying the surface need their own hypotheses.
Practice
Quick check
(For , choose and a unit , compute and , and identify the tangent plane.)
The rulings can be taken parallel to the -axis.
Solution · Answer
Take and . Then , and . The tangent plane is the -plane everywhere.
Quick check
(For the helicoid above, compute the mixed second-form coefficient in the normal convention used in the proof.)
Use .
Solution · Answer
Since and , the convention gives . Reversing reverses this sign but leaves unchanged.
Quick check
(For , determine all regular points and compute . Explain why this is ruled even though its -direction is not unit in this parametrization.)
Compute and directly.
Solution
, , and their cross product is , never zero, so every point is regular. A unit normal is this cross product divided by . The pure second derivatives vanish and , so and . For fixed , traces a line; normalization is not needed to recognize the ruling.
Quick check
(For the cone example, what does the regularity test say at and at ? Why must the two cases not be conflated?)
Evaluate .
Solution · Answer
At , and the parametrization is singular. At , is nonzero and . The second conclusion relies on a positive metric determinant and cannot simply be transferred to the first.
Quick check
(Suppose at a single and . What can be concluded on that ruling, and what cannot be concluded about nearby rulings?)
A pointwise condition at one says nothing about derivatives nearby.
Solution · Answer
is independent of and nonzero, so the ruling is regular and has a constant tangent plane; there. One cannot conclude that remains constant on an interval or that a neighborhood is a cylinder.
Quick check
(Show that changing the sign of and replacing by leaves the geometric ruled family and the curvature formula unchanged.)
Track the signs in , in and in .
Solution
The substitutions , leave unchanged. In the triple product both and change sign, leaving unchanged; the cross product changes sign, leaving its norm and unchanged.
Quick check
(If and , explain how locates the possible rank failure. What happens if ?)
Specialize the regularity square.
Solution · Answer
The regularity square becomes . It vanishes only at . If , every point of this ruling in the chosen parameter domain is regular.
Quick check
(For a unit-speed curve with on an interval, what happens to its tangent-surface parametrization?)
Compare with .
Solution · Answer
is constant on that interval and is a straight line. Then , so the tangent parametrization has rank one everywhere there. It does not produce a regular surface patch.
This note gives a local curvature and tangent-plane criterion for the stated ruled parametrization. Global developable-surface classification, singularity theory and global isometric unrolling remain separate questions.