Motivation
A parametrized curve carries both a path and a choice of speed. To describe the shape of the path, first remove the effect of speed. Curvature measures how rapidly the direction of travel changes with distance; torsion measures how the osculating plane turns out of itself.
Definitions
Arc length and curvature
Definition 1.1.1
(Regular curve and arc length)
A curve is regular when for every . Its arc length from is
Since , the function is strictly increasing and locally invertible, so the curve can be reparametrized by .
Definition 1.1.2
(Unit tangent and curvature)
For a regular curve reparametrized by arc length, the unit tangent is , so , and the curvature is .
In practice a curve rarely arrives in arc length, so we need the curvature in the given parameter.
Theorem 1.1.3
(Curvature in an arbitrary parameter)
For a regular curve,
Proof
(Separating speed from turning)
Let and , and write . Then , so because . Differentiating gives , hence . Dividing by gives the formula.
Common mistake
(Using the unit-speed formula in another parameter)
The formula holds only for unit speed. For , an arc of the unit circle, at one finds , of length , whereas the true curvature is . The extra acceleration measures change of speed, not turning.
Theorem/proposition
The moving frame
Definition 1.1.4
(Frenet frame and torsion)
Assume is , unit speed and , and let primes mean . The principal normal is and the binormal is . The ordered orthonormal triple is the Frenet frame, and the torsion is .
Positive curvature is essential: on a straight line , so and are not determined by these definitions.
Theorem 1.1.5
(Frenet equations)
With this sign convention,
Proof
(Differentiating the orthonormality relations)
The first equation is the definition of . Since , is orthogonal to , and , so is a multiple of ; the definition of gives the coefficient . Finally , and , which is the middle equation.
Concept lensGeometric
The frame rotates with an angular velocity vector
The three Frenet equations are a single rotation law. Put , the Darboux vector. Then
as one checks from , and . At each instant the frame turns rigidly about the axis with angular speed : curvature is the component of the rotation about the binormal, torsion the component about the tangent.
Worked examples
Example: a circular helix
Worked example 1.1.6
(A circular helix)
Let , , and . Its speed is , so up to a constant. Direct differentiation gives
For example, and . Then ; differentiating with respect to verifies the torsion. If the curve is a plane circle and torsion is zero. The converse locally holds wherever the Frenet frame exists: makes constant, and , so the curve lies in a plane.
Torsion in an arbitrary parameter
The Frenet frame is defined using arc length, but a given curve may come in a different parameter.
Theorem 1.1.7
(Torsion in an arbitrary parameter)
If is , regular, and , then the curvature is positive and
Proof
(Reading off the binormal component)
To derive it without assuming unit speed, put . Differentiating with respect to gives
The coefficient of in is : only differentiating the term contributes to that component. The scalar triple product is therefore . Meanwhile . Dividing yields the displayed formula. Its denominator vanishes wherever : even an isolated inflection point has no Frenet normal by this construction.
Example: reparametrizing a circle
Worked example 1.1.8
(Reparametrizing a circle)
Let on . Its speed is not constant, but the path is an arc of the unit circle. Directly, , so the curvature formula gives . If the domain is extended to , the velocity there vanishes; the arbitrary-parameter formula has denominator zero there even though the image lies on a smooth circle. A singular parametrization can fail to describe a regular curve at a point of an otherwise regular geometric path.
Example: a planar parabola
Worked example 1.1.9
(A planar parabola)
For , velocity is never zero and acceleration is . Thus
The curvature is maximal at the vertex and tends to zero as grows. This does not say the parabola becomes a straight line at any finite parameter: everywhere. The torsion vanishes because the entire curve lies in one plane; the determinant in the torsion formula has a zero third coordinate in every column.
What curvature and torsion determine
The fundamental theorem of space curves states the converse to the construction of the frame.
Theorem 1.1.10
(Fundamental theorem of space curves)
Let be a function and a continuous function on an interval. There is a unit-speed curve with curvature and torsion , and any two such curves differ by an orientation-preserving rigid motion.
Its proof, given below, solves the Frenet differential equations with an initial orthonormal frame, then integrates ; we do not prove the necessary existence and uniqueness theorem for ordinary differential equations here. The conclusion is local-to-global on the given interval, not a guarantee that a periodic pair of functions produces a closed curve.
For instance, constant positive curvature and zero torsion give a circle locally, but traversing the complete circle is a further statement about the parameter interval. The positive-curvature assumption is structural: when vanishes, torsion as defined by the Frenet frame is not available and the stated uniqueness theorem cannot simply be applied.
Signed turning in the plane
For a regular plane curve with a fixed orientation of the plane, define its signed curvature by
The unsigned spatial curvature of the same curve is . Locally choose a continuous angle for the unit tangent, so and is the left unit normal. Then . The determinant formula above equals , as follows by differentiating . Thus its sign distinguishes turning left from turning right; reversing the direction of traversal reverses the sign of at corresponding points. Signed curvature can pass continuously through zero, even where the Frenet normal ceases to be defined.
Example: an inflection
For , the velocity never vanishes. Its signed curvature is
It changes sign at zero. The unsigned curvature is , so it is zero there. The curve remains smooth and regular, but the Frenet normal is undefined exactly at that point. The left normal , which uses the chosen orientation of the plane rather than division by curvature, is still defined. This distinction is useful at inflections and explains why the two notions of normal should not be conflated.
Example: a genuinely spatial curve
Let . Here , , and . The cross product is and the triple product is . Consequently
Both expressions are defined for every real , and torsion is positive everywhere under our convention. In particular, the curve cannot lie in a plane on any interval: a planar curve with positive curvature has zero torsion. This gives an algebraic test for nonplanarity without relying on a picture.
Why the fundamental theorem has its hypotheses
Proof
(Solving the Frenet system and integrating the tangent)
The existence and uniqueness statement can be reduced to a linear ordinary differential equation. Choose a starting point and an oriented orthonormal triple . Seek vector functions satisfying the three Frenet equations and those initial values. This is a linear system with continuous coefficients, so the standard existence and uniqueness theorem for linear ODEs supplies a solution on the interval. We use that ODE theorem without proving it here.
The initial frame is not automatically preserved merely because its entries solve a linear system; it must be checked. Differentiate all six independent inner products. For example, and
The six inner products therefore solve a homogeneous linear system after subtracting their desired constant values. The orthonormal values satisfy that system and the initial conditions, so uniqueness forces them to hold throughout. Continuity preserves orientation, because an orthonormal frame has determinant either one or minus one and starts with determinant one.
Now define . It has unit speed and curvature , because and . The prescribed is and its derivative gives the prescribed torsion. If is and is continuous, the equations provide enough differentiability for a curve. Another curve with the same invariants and the same initial point and frame satisfies the same ODE and is identical. For different initial data, a unique orientation-preserving rigid motion matches the two initial oriented frames and points; uniqueness then matches the curves. This explains exactly where the external ODE result enters the proof.
Proof X-ray
What each hypothesis does in the reconstruction
The proof has three stages. Linear ODE theory gives a frame solving the Frenet system; this needs only continuity of and . The non-obvious step is that the solution stays orthonormal: the six inner products satisfy their own linear system, the constant orthonormal values solve it, and uniqueness forces the solution to be those constants. Integrating then produces the curve, and here is used, because only then is the solved , so that the curve's own Frenet frame and torsion are the prescribed ones. Uniqueness closes the argument: a rigid motion matches initial data, and the same ODE uniqueness matches everything after.
The theorem does not assert uniqueness after discarding the torsion sign. Reflection reverses the orientation of space and can reverse signed torsion while preserving unsigned curvature. Likewise, a curve specified only by a curvature function may admit many noncongruent spatial realizations with different torsions. The Frenet data describe a parametrized oriented curve, and the initial frame selects its placement. The hypothesis is just as necessary.
Counterexample mode
Uniqueness fails where curvature vanishes
Claim: unit-speed curves with the same curvature function are congruent whenever their torsions agree wherever defined. Let and define two unit tangents: for all , and for but for . Integrating gives curves and . Both pieces of have derivative of length and both vanish to second order at , so is , is , and . Each piece is planar, so wherever . Yet lies in the -plane, while uses directions in the -plane for and in the -plane for , so lies in no plane. Rigid motions preserve planarity, so and are not congruent. The theorem's hypothesis rules this out: at the Frenet frame does not exist, and the osculating plane may jump there.
A turning-angle calculation
For a unit-speed plane curve, write . Its signed curvature is . If the signed curvature is the positive constant , integration gives . A second integration gives a circle of radius , up to a planar rigid motion and a choice of the parameter interval. If the signed curvature is zero throughout an interval, is constant and the curve is a line segment there.
This calculation has two separate integrations: curvature specifies the change of tangent direction; the tangent specifies the change of position. The integration constants record initial direction and position. On a closed curve, local tangent angles may require compatible choices around the loop, so one should not infer that an arbitrary prescribed curvature automatically produces a closed path. Closure requires the integral of the tangent over the parameter period to vanish as well as matching endpoint data.
Checking the data of a proposed curve
Suppose someone prescribes positive constant curvature and constant torsion . The helix calculation gives an explicit model: set
Since , the helix defined earlier is regular, and substitution gives exactly . If , then and this model is a circle. For nonzero torsion it is genuinely spatial. The fundamental theorem says every other unit-speed curve with the same constants is obtained from a suitable unit-speed parametrization of this model by a rigid motion preserving orientation, on corresponding intervals.
This example shows why checking units and parameter speed matters. The displayed helix parameter is not arc length unless . Replacing by supplies unit speed. The values of curvature and torsion do not require the original parameter itself to have unit speed, because their arbitrary-parameter formulas already compensate for it. A reparametrization with vanishing derivative would not be allowed in that argument.
Changing the direction of the parameter
For a regular change of parameter with nonzero derivative, the chain rule shows that the numerator and denominator in the arbitrary-parameter curvature formula acquire the same factor . In the torsion formula both acquire the factor . Thus both unsigned curvature and the torsion defined here are unchanged at corresponding points, even when the parameter direction is reversed. The calculation assumes the necessary derivatives and a nonzero parameter derivative; it cannot be applied at a singular change of parameter.
Common mistake
(Expecting torsion to change sign under reversal)
Reversing the parameter changes the signed planar curvature, but not torsion: for the helix with , the reversed parametrization still has . What reverses the sign of torsion is a reflection of space, which turns a right-handed helix into a left-handed one. The two definitions use different orientation data, so the formulas do not contradict each other.
A regular curve can be studied in overlapping parameter intervals; the local computations agree on overlaps under a regular change of parameter. This allows a curve to pass beyond one convenient chart without attributing a singularity to the geometric image. The frame still requires positive curvature at the point in question.
Yes: along every regular curve there is a frame that turns only as much as the tangent forces, but it is not canonical.
A natural next question
Is there a frame that survives where curvature vanishes?
Yes: along every regular curve there is a frame that turns only as much as the tangent forces, but it is not canonical.
For a unit-speed curve, choose a unit vector and solve the linear equation with . Then and , so stays a unit normal. With one finds , and , where . No division by occurs; the price is that the frame depends on , so is determined only up to a constant rotation.
Exercises
Quick check
(Find the curvature of the circle , .)
Solution · Answer
The speed is and , so .
Quick check
(If vanishes everywhere, is a regular connected curve a straight line?)
Solution · Answer
Yes: in arc length, , so is constant on the connected parameter interval and integration gives . A line has no canonical Frenet normal; zero curvature is not a valid input to the formula .
Further practice
Quick check
(For , find and and explain what nonzero torsion says about planarity near zero.)
Solution · Answer
Setting in the formulas above gives and . If a neighborhood lay in a plane, its binormal would be constant wherever curvature is positive, forcing torsion zero; hence no such neighborhood is planar.
Quick check
(Compute signed curvature for , . Why does this not contradict the positive curvature of the same circle traversed counterclockwise?)
Solution · Answer
The determinant is and speed is , so . Unsigned curvature is in either traversal. The signed value also records direction relative to the chosen plane orientation.