An integral needs a physical quantity to accumulate
A volume integral does not automatically give work, and a pressure is not yet a force. Before choosing a variable, identify the small contribution to the requested quantity. Its units should already be correct before the pieces are added.
For a force component along a straight displacement, the elementary work model is force times displacement. If that component varies continuously with position, finite work sums lead to . Force is measured in newtons, displacement in meters, and work in joules. The sign records whether the force assists or opposes the chosen displacement. Replacing a changing force by its final value is not justified merely because the final position is known.
Pumping uses a different convenient slicing variable: the initial height of a parcel of liquid. Hydrostatic force uses depth below the free surface. These variables may point in opposite directions. Choosing their origins and positive directions explicitly prevents a height from being confused with a lift distance or a depth.
A pumping model and its assumptions
Let a tank contain liquid between heights and , with continuous nonnegative horizontal section area . Assume constant mass density and gravitational acceleration . All liquid is discharged at a fixed height .
We calculate ideal mechanical work: gravitational potential-energy increase, with negligible change in kinetic energy, no frictional loss and equal atmospheric pressure at the vented tank and discharge. The calculation is not automatically electrical energy drawn by a real pump. Those extra effects require additional model data.
A horizontal parcel initially at height must rise . A slice of volume has weight , so the candidate work is the integral stated below. Here the lift distance varies with the slice. It is not the same as the initial water depth, the outlet height alone, or the distance from the tank's top to the outlet.
Proposition 5.8.1
(Ideal pumping work)
Let be continuous and nonnegative on , let and be constant, and let . Under the ideal assumptions above, the work needed to raise all the liquid to height (the increase in gravitational potential energy) is
Proof
(Bracketing each layer's varying lift)
Partition with mesh . The layer has volume , and every parcel in it has weight density and lift distance between and . Its work therefore satisfies
Because , the pointwise inequalities hold on the layer. Integrating them shows that the layer part of the candidate integral lies between the same two numbers. Summing over , both and lie in , where and are the sums of the left and right bounds. Their difference is
with the total initial volume. Hence for every partition. The number does not depend on the partition, and can be made arbitrarily small, so . Continuity of guarantees that every and the integral exist.
Proof X-ray
Where the bracketing proof does its work
The key move is to bound a layer's work from both sides instead of freezing the lift at one height: the lift distance genuinely varies inside a layer, so no single value is exact, but its extreme values trap the truth. The hypothesis is used exactly once, to keep the direction of the pointwise inequalities when multiplying by ; a negative section area would reverse them and the two sums would no longer enclose the integral. The hypotheses fix the direction of the bracket in the same way. The condition makes every lift distance nonnegative, so the model really describes raising liquid. The argument closes because the bracket width is at most and tends to zero, while the number is fixed. Without that last remark, one would only have shown that the sums approach the integral, not that the physical work equals it.
The height variable labels initial material or, equivalently for this constant-density model, accounts for the initial gravitational energy distribution. One need not know the time-dependent flow rate to find the ideal total work. A flow rate would be needed for questions about power or elapsed time; total energy and energy per unit time are different quantities.
Density, weight density and a useful energy check
Definition 5.8.2
(Weight density and volume-weighted mean height)
The mass density has units kilograms per cubic meter; multiplying by gravity gives the weight density in newtons per cubic meter. For a tank with total initial volume , the volume-weighted mean height of the liquid is
In the pumping integrand, section area, lift distance and slice thickness contribute four powers of length; multiplying by weight density leaves newton-meters, as work requires.
Linearity rewrites the work as . This is the total weight times the volume-weighted mean lift. An arithmetic midpoint height is valid only when it agrees with that weighted mean. A tank that widens upward places more liquid at higher levels, changing the average even if its total depth stays fixed.
Common mistake
(Using the midpoint height or the full depth as the lift)
For a tank of constant section area the volume-weighted mean height is the midpoint , so the midpoint shortcut is correct there. For a widening tank it is not: with on the mean height is , not . Writing would then give joules instead of the correct joules. Equally wrong is using the initial depth , or the distance from the rim to the outlet, as the lift of every slice. Always start from the slice at height and its own lift .
Quick check
(A full cylindrical tank has constant section area and height m. All the liquid is pumped to an outlet at height m. Find the ideal work in terms of , and .)
Integrate the lift over the constant section area.
Solution · Answer
. As a check, , the mean height is , so the mean lift is and .
If a constant efficiency is explicitly assumed, and useful mechanical work is the fraction of input energy, then input energy is . If and , multiplying by efficiency instead would predict less input energy than useful output; at or the two are equal. The assumption that one constant efficiency describes the entire process is part of that model.
Hydrostatic pressure comes from equilibrium
Now let denote depth downward from a horizontal free surface in a stationary liquid of constant density. Assume pressure acts normally to a surface. Consider a vertical fluid column of horizontal area from the free surface to depth . Its weight is . Its upper pressure is atmospheric pressure , and its vertical side faces contribute no vertical pressure force.
Vertical equilibrium therefore gives . Dividing by the positive area yields
Definition 5.8.3
(Gauge pressure)
The difference is the gauge pressure at depth : the pressure in excess of the atmospheric pressure acting on the free surface.
If the other face of a plate is exposed to the same atmospheric pressure, the atmospheric parts cancel in the net force. Density and gravity must be constant for this particular linear depth formula. A varying density requires a fresh column-weight calculation.
Proposition 5.8.4
(Force on a submerged vertical plate)
Let a fully submerged vertical flat plate have horizontal width at depth , where is continuous and nonnegative on with . Let and be constant, and let the plate's other face be at atmospheric pressure. Then the net force is normal to the plate and has magnitude
Proof
(Bracketing the pressure on each strip)
All pressure forces are parallel to the plate normal, so their magnitudes add. Partition with mesh and let be the area of the th strip. The pressure on that strip lies between and , so its force satisfies . Since , the pointwise inequalities show that the strip part of the candidate integral lies between the same bounds. The two bounds differ by , so the total gap is at most , where is the plate area. The true force and the integral differ by at most for every partition, hence they are equal. The force formula therefore follows from area slicing and pressure variation, not from multiplying one arbitrary pressure by the entire plate area.
Definition 5.8.5
(Area-weighted depth)
If the plate area , its area-weighted depth is
By the theorem, : pressure at the weighted depth times area gives the force magnitude. Constant width makes this depth the interval midpoint. For another shape, that midpoint shortcut requires a new justification. The identity concerns the magnitude of parallel pressure forces, not their line of action. If the area is zero, use the original integral to obtain zero force without dividing by area.
Common mistake
(Measuring depth from the wrong origin)
The integrand uses the depth below the free surface, which grows downward. A coordinate measured upward from the bottom of the tank, such as the height in the pumping model, cannot be inserted for . For a plate whose top edge is at depth and bottom edge at depth , replacing by the height above the bottom would give instead of the correct . Choose one variable, state its origin and positive direction, and convert the limits and the width function together.
Quick check
(A vertical rectangular plate m wide has its top edge at depth m and its bottom edge at depth m, with water on one side and air on the other. Find the net force in terms of .)
Use on .
Solution · Answer
. As a check, the area is and the weighted depth is the midpoint , so .
Worked examples
Worked example 5.8.6
(A widening tank and an outlet above its rim)
Question. A tank initially contains water from height zero to meters. At numerical height in meters, its horizontal section area is square meters. Pump all water to an outlet at height meters. Use kilograms per cubic meter and meters per second squared. Find its volume, ideal work, and input energy if constant efficiency is .
Solution. The coefficient in the numerical area formula includes the stated unit convention. Integrating gives
The volume is in cubic meters. Each slice rises , so
The work is in joules. As an independent energy check, the initial first volume moment is , giving . Hence the weighted lift is , and total weight times that lift gives the same work. Using the geometric midpoint instead would treat unequal amounts of liquid as if they were equally distributed in height.
Finally joules. This is an input-energy prediction under the stated efficiency assumption, not a claim about a particular pump's measured consumption.
Worked example 5.8.7
(A cone emptied at its rim)
Question. A full tank is an inverted cone with its apex at the bottom: its horizontal section at height meters is a disk of radius , for . Find the ideal work to pump all the water over the rim, so that , in terms of .
Solution. The section area is and the lift is . Hence
As a check, and , so and , the same value. This is the edge case : the liquid at the very top has lift zero and contributes nothing, and the large upper layers contribute little because their lift is small. A midpoint height would give , twice the correct work.
Worked example 5.8.8
(A triangular plate is not a rectangular strip)
Question. A vertical triangular plate has its upper vertex at depth meter and a horizontal base of width meters at depth meters. Water is on one side and atmospheric air on the other. Use the same density and gravity as in the previous example. Find the net hydrostatic force and explain which average depth works.
Solution. Similar triangles give the width on . Thus
The force is in newtons. The plate area is square meters. Its area-weighted depth is meters. Pressure at that depth times area gives exactly the same force, because pressure is linear in depth.
The midpoint of the depth interval is , which is not the area-weighted depth: more plate area lies near the base. Using that midpoint would give newtons. The weighted identity determines the force magnitude; the line of action would require a separate moment calculation.
A domain counterexample: dry material has no negative water pressure
The pressure formula and the force integral were derived only below the free surface. When part of a plate is above the water, that part must not be fed into the same integral.
Counterexample mode
Integrating the force formula through dry material
Claim: the net water force on a vertical rectangle of width whose depth variable runs from to (so that the free surface cuts it) is . Compute it: . Yet the part of the plate between depths and is under water, where the pressure is positive on every point of it, so the force cannot be zero. The integral canceled a negative contribution from depths to , which would correspond to a negative water pressure on dry material. With air at the same atmospheric pressure on both faces of the dry portion, only depths to contribute, and the correct net force is . The repaired statement restricts the integral to the submerged depths, , exactly the hypothesis of the force proposition.
The physical domain is part of the mathematics, just as the lift distance and density assumptions were part of the pumping model.
Exercises
Exercise 5.8.9
(Show that in the pumping model with the work equals , and use this to find the work for a full tank with on , outlet at , in terms of .)
Core
Hint(1)
Split into minus and use linearity of the integral.
Solution(3)
- 1
Expand the integrand and use linearity
Key step
- 2
Compute the volume and the first moment
- 3
Apply the identity and check by direct integration
. Directly, , which agrees.
Quick check
(A battery supplies a pump that is efficient, and the ideal work to lift the water is joules. How much input energy is needed?)
Use .
Solution · Answer
joules. Multiplying instead, joules, would predict less energy than the useful output, which is impossible for .