Differentiate the relationship while quantities can still vary
Definition 4.4.1
(Constraint and related rates)
A constraint is an equation that holds at every instant of a motion. Two rates and are related rates when the constraint ties them together: differentiating the constraint in time gives an equation linking and .
Suppose and are differentiable on a time interval and satisfy , where has continuous first partial derivatives near the path.
Proposition 4.4.2
(Differentiated constraint)
Under these assumptions, at every instant
If at an instant, then there. If and , then at that instant.
Proof
(Chain rule applied to a constant function)
Continuous first partial derivatives make differentiable, so the chain rule applies to . This function is identically , so its derivative is , which is the displayed relation. Solving for needs . If , the relation reads , and forces .
This is a necessary relation for the stated differentiable motion. A denominator of zero must be treated in the original equation; dividing by it does not produce a rate. The equation itself does not assert that a physical trajectory exists or that it continues to satisfy the model.
A reliable workflow is: define variables and signs; state the constraint and differentiability assumptions; differentiate with respect to time; only then insert the values at the instant. The coordinates at an instant are numbers, but they are values of changing functions, not constants to substitute before differentiation. Units offer an independent check: a length derivative has units of length per time, whereas an area derivative has units of area per time.
Counterexample mode
Without a nonzero y-derivative of the constraint, the rate of x does not determine the rate of y
Claim: along a path on , the rate always determines . Take the point , where . The two differentiable paths and both satisfy the constraint and pass through at . For the first, and ; for the second, and . The same gives different values of , so does not determine at that point. The repair is the hypothesis .
Worked example: A moving point and the sign of a branch
Worked example 4.4.3
(Two branches of a hyperbola)
Problem. A differentiable path lies on . At an instant, and unit per second. Determine separately when and when . Explain what the differentiated constraint says at if .
Solution. Differentiate before inserting values:
At this gives unit per second. At it gives unit per second. Both points satisfy the same constraint, but the branch changes the sign. Squaring a relation and then choosing only the positive root would lose the second possibility.
At , the constraint gives , so . The undivided derivative equation requires , hence for any differentiable path satisfying the constraint at that instant. A proposed nonzero is inconsistent with those assumptions; one cannot calculate by dividing by zero.
Worked example: Fixed volume, changing surface area
Worked example 4.4.4
(Cylinder of fixed volume)
Problem. A closed right circular cylinder changes shape while its volume remains cubic centimeters. At an instant its radius is 5 cm and increasing at cm/s. Assuming differentiable positive radius and height, find the height rate and the rate of change of total surface area, including both circular ends.
Solution. The constraint gives cm at . Differentiate with respect to time:
The negative sign means the height falls while the radius grows. The total area is , so
Substitution gives square centimeters per second. As an independent check, the constraint gives and hence . Differentiating this one-variable expression and multiplying by at again gives . The rate would differ if the end disks were excluded or the volume were changing.
Worked example: A sliding ladder and its endpoint
Worked example 4.4.5
(Ladder against a wall)
A ladder of length m has its foot at distance from the wall and its top at height , so . When the foot moves away at m/s. Differentiating, . At we have , so m/s: the top slides down. The units are meters per second on both sides.
The edge case is , where the ladder lies on the floor with . There the differentiated constraint reads , so . A foot still moving at m/s is incompatible with the model at that instant, and the formula would give an unbounded rate. The model stops describing a real ladder before the top reaches the floor.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Substituting the instant's values before differentiating)
At on , putting first gives , and differentiating this gives , hence the false claim . The correct value, with , is . The number is the value of at one instant; is still changing, which is what the term records.
Common mistake
(Losing a branch by choosing a root early)
Writing before differentiating covers only the points with . The derivative is then positive for , and the answer at is missed. Differentiating the constraint implicitly keeps both branches, with the sign carried by .
Exercises
Quick check
(A circle of radius has area . If cm and cm/s, find with units.)
Differentiate with respect to time first.
Solution · Answer
cm/s. Area per time is the correct unit for an area derivative.
Quick check
(For the fixed-volume cylinder, suppose instead the volume increases at cm/s. With , , , find .)
The constraint is no longer constant: differentiate and set .
Solution · Answer
, so and cm/s.
Exercise 4.4.6
(A differentiable path lies on the circle and passes through with . Find there. Then find at the point for any such path.)
Core
Solution(3)
- 1
Differentiate the constraint
, so at every instant.
- 2
Insert the instant's values
Key step
At with : , so .
Because: Substitution is allowed only after differentiating.
- 3
Read off the point
At the relation is , so whatever is: the path moves vertically there, and is not determined by .