Convergence known at only some points
Suppose a sequence of holomorphic functions is easy to evaluate on the real axis but difficult to control at complex arguments. Pointwise information alone usually says little about uniform convergence. Local boundedness supplies compactness, while the identity theorem makes all possible subsequential limits agree. Vitali's theorem joins these two ideas: convergence on a set with an interior accumulation point then determines the entire limit.
Definition 2.2.1
(Locally bounded sequence)
Let be a domain. A sequence of functions on is locally bounded if for every compact there is a bound with for every and every .
The bound must be common to the sequence. For example, each constant function is individually bounded on every compact set, but the sequence is not locally bounded.
The theorem and its mechanism
Theorem 2.2.2
(Vitali convergence theorem)
Let be a locally bounded sequence of holomorphic functions on a domain . Suppose converges for every in a set having an accumulation point in . Then there is a holomorphic on such that uniformly on every compact subset of , and for .
Proof
(Compactness, identification of every cluster limit, and a contradiction)
Montel's theorem gives a subsequence converging locally uniformly to a finite holomorphic function . For each , every subsequence has the same pointwise limit as the full sequence, so .
Any other locally uniformly convergent subsequence has a holomorphic limit agreeing with on . Since has an accumulation point in and is connected, the identity theorem gives throughout .
To obtain convergence of the whole sequence, suppose it fails on a compact . Then there are and a subsequence with for every . Local boundedness still holds for this subsequence, so Montel gives a further subsequence converging locally uniformly to a holomorphic function, which the previous paragraph forces to be . Its uniform convergence to on contradicts the lower bound . Thus the whole sequence converges to uniformly on each compact set.
The proof never estimates directly. It works entirely through subsequences, and each hypothesis enters at one identifiable step.
Proof X-ray
Compactness gives a candidate; uniqueness gives the full limit
Local boundedness is used twice, both times through Montel's theorem: once to produce the candidate , and again inside the contradiction, applied to the bad subsequence. Montel alone supplies convergent subsequences and does not identify their limits; different subsequences of an arbitrary bounded sequence can converge to different functions.
Pointwise convergence on is used only to make every cluster limit agree on . The identity theorem then upgrades agreement on to agreement on , and this is the step that needs both the accumulation point inside and connectedness. On a disconnected open set, convergence on one component says nothing about another.
The closing move is the standard subsequence principle: if every subsequence has a further subsequence converging to the same , the whole sequence converges to . The contradiction removes any need for a convergence rate.
The accumulation point cannot be weakened to infinitely many points.
Counterexample mode
A discrete convergence set is not enough
Claim: a locally bounded holomorphic sequence converging at infinitely many points converges locally uniformly. On , let . The sequence is locally bounded because it alternates between the two entire functions . At every integer , , so for all and the sequence converges there. At , however, , which does not converge. The integers have no accumulation point in , so the identity theorem cannot identify the two cluster limits and . The hypothesis needed is an accumulation point inside the domain.
Local boundedness is also essential. The sequence converges at the single point zero but is unbounded on any disk of positive radius; this example alone does not isolate the boundedness hypothesis, because its convergence set also lacks an accumulation point. A sharper example is on : it converges on the open unit disk, but diverges. The sequence is not locally bounded near , so there is no holomorphic limit on all of . Restricting the same sequence to restores local boundedness, and the theorem applies.
Common mistake
(An accumulation point on the boundary does not count)
The accumulation point must lie in . On , let , whose only accumulation point is . Since , the Blaschke product with zeros at the points of is a nonzero bounded holomorphic function on . Then is uniformly bounded and converges to zero at every point of , but it fails to converge wherever .
Worked examples
Worked example 2.2.3
(Powers in the disk)
On , the sequence is locally bounded, in fact . It converges to zero on the interval , which has accumulation points in the disk, for instance . Vitali therefore gives locally uniform convergence to zero. Here the direct estimate for also proves the conclusion. Neither argument gives uniform convergence on all of , where the supremum of is one for every .
Worked example 2.2.4
(Limits on a real interval determine the complex limit)
Suppose holomorphic are uniformly bounded by on and converge at every point of . The disk is connected and has accumulation points in it, so Vitali gives a holomorphic limit and uniform convergence on every closed disk . The limit also satisfies , since each . The theorem does not supply a formula for : that requires knowing the values on the interval, after which the identity theorem pins down.
Worked example 2.2.5
(The exponential as a limit of polynomials)
Let . Fix . For ,
so the sequence is locally bounded on . For real , the familiar limit holds, so the sequence converges on , which has accumulation points in the disk. Vitali gives a holomorphic limit on that agrees with on , and the identity theorem makes it . As is arbitrary and every compact subset of lies in some , locally uniformly on . By the derivative result below, also locally uniformly.
Derivatives and the scope of the conclusion
A locally uniform limit of holomorphic functions can be differentiated term by term, again only on compact sets.
Corollary 2.2.6
(Convergence of derivatives)
If holomorphic uniformly on compact subsets of , then for every , uniformly on compact subsets of .
Proof
(Cauchy's estimate on a neighborhood)
For a compact set , choose small enough that the closed -neighborhood lies in . Applying Cauchy's integral formula for the -th derivative of on the circle of radius about each gives
The right side tends to zero because is compact. Therefore uniformly on for every fixed .
Common mistake
(Dropping the compact qualifier for derivatives)
In the powers example, converges to zero uniformly on each disk , since . Its supremum on the whole open disk is , so there is no uniform convergence on . The derivative conclusion is a consequence of complex analyticity and compact convergence; even uniform convergence of differentiable real functions does not generally permit differentiation of limits.
Practice and solutions
Quick check
(Let be holomorphic on with there. If for every , identify the locally uniform limit.)
Combine Vitali with the identity theorem.
Solution · Answer
Vitali gives a holomorphic limit agreeing with on . The identity theorem makes it throughout , and the convergence is locally uniform there. The bound is consistent: on that disk.
Quick check
(Why does not contradict Vitali's theorem on ?)
Look at the set where the sequence converges.
Solution · Answer
The sequence converges on the integers and nowhere else, since off the integers. The integers have no accumulation point in , so the hypothesis of Vitali's theorem fails; the sequence indeed fails to converge at .
Quick check
(The hypotheses of Vitali's theorem hold, , and for every . What is for the limit function?)
Derivatives converge on compact sets, in particular at a point.
Solution · Answer
By the convergence of derivatives, applied to the compact set , .
Quick check
(Can converge uniformly to zero on the whole unit disk?)
Compute the supremum of over .
Solution · Answer
No. For every , , so the uniform error from zero never tends to zero. Vitali gives only convergence on compact subsets.