Complex differentiability is much stronger than it first appears. A single derivative at every point of a domain forces not just contour cancellation, but locally convergent power series and derivatives of every order. The important point is the order of proof: we must not assume the derivative is continuous or a power series already exists in order to establish those consequences.
Definition 5.1.1
(Holomorphic function)
A function is holomorphic on an open set if it is complex differentiable at every point of that set.
Complex differentiability implies continuity at that point. Contour integrals below are taken over piecewise continuously differentiable curves with their stated orientation; for a triangle, the boundary is traversed counterclockwise. We use elementary complex differentiation rules and ordinary estimates for contour integrals.
Goursat's triangle theorem
Theorem 5.1.2
(Cancellation on a triangle)
Let be holomorphic on an open set containing a closed triangle and its interior. Then
No continuity assumption on is needed.
Proof
(A nested triangle exposes a nonzero integral)
Write . Join the side midpoints to divide into four closed triangles. Their counterclockwise boundary integrals add to , since every internal edge occurs twice with opposite orientation. Choose a subtriangle whose integral has modulus at least . Repeat inside it, choosing nested triangles with
The nested compact triangles have a common point . Differentiability there says
The affine part has a polynomial primitive, so its integral around each is zero. Given , all sufficiently large lie where . Thus
Multiply by and let to obtain . Degenerate triangles have zero boundary integral directly.
Proof X-ray
The shrinking error is exactly second order
The subdivision reduces both diameter and perimeter by each time. Differentiability supplies a remainder smaller than times the diameter; integrating around the boundary adds the perimeter. These two factors cancel the used to select a large subtriangle. No estimate for variation of is used.
Corollary 5.1.3
(Primitives on a disk)
Let be holomorphic on an open disk . Then has a primitive on , and for every closed piecewise curve in .
Proof
(Integrate along segments from a fixed point)
Fix in the disk and define . For small , the triangle with vertices lies in the disk, and (1) gives . Dividing by and using continuity at yields . Hence its integral around any closed piecewise curve lying in that disk is zero, by the chain rule.
The disk's convexity is what keeps the triangles inside; we have not proved a general-domain theorem here.
From disks to a general domain. The prerequisite MATH2230 note “Contours, primitives and the Cauchy–Goursat theorem” proves the bridge used later in this course. If two piecewise paths in a domain have the same endpoints and are homotopic there with endpoints fixed, a holomorphic function has equal integrals along them. The homotopy need only be continuous: the parameter square can be subdivided into cells whose images lie in disks with local primitives. In a simply connected domain every closed contour can be contracted, so every period is zero. Conversely, for a continuous function on any domain, zero integrals around all closed contours give a primitive by integrating from a fixed base point; a primitive also forces all periods to vanish. Thus simple connectivity is a sufficient condition for every holomorphic function to have a primitive, not a necessary condition for a particular function. For example, has primitive on , but has period on the positively oriented unit circle. The disk argument above supplies local primitives; it does not by itself remove this global obstruction.
A continuous isolated exception
We need a small lemma before applying the triangle theorem to a difference quotient.
Lemma 5.1.4
(One continuous exceptional point)
Suppose is continuous on an open set containing a closed disk , and holomorphic there except possibly at one interior point . Then
Proof
(Shrink a polygon toward the exceptional point)
To prove this without assuming a removable-singularity theorem, take a regular inscribed -gon . It contains , so lies in its interior for all sufficiently large . For , let . The region between the two homothetic polygons is a finite union of quadrilaterals, each split into triangles contained in and outside the interior of , so they avoid . Each triangle is a compact subset of the open set where is holomorphic, so Goursat’s theorem applies. Internal edges cancel, giving . The inner perimeter tends to zero with while is bounded on the disk, so the right side tends to zero. Let . Parametrize each polygon by linear interpolation between successive circle points at equally spaced angles. These parametrizations converge uniformly to ; their piecewise derivatives converge uniformly to away from vertices and remain uniformly bounded. Uniform continuity and boundedness of on the compact disk therefore make the polygon integrals converge to the circle integral. This proves (2). It permits one continuous exceptional point; it is not a claim about a pole.
Cauchy's disk formula and Taylor series
Theorem 5.1.5
(Cauchy's integral formula on a disk)
Let be holomorphic on an open set containing , with . For every with ,
The circle is positively oriented.
Proof
(Subtract the value before dividing)
For fixed inside the circle, put
The definition of derivative makes continuous at ; it is holomorphic away from . The preceding lemma gives . Also : on the circle, expand uniformly, then integrate term by term. Only the term survives. Hence , proving (3).
Theorem 5.1.6
(Power series, derivatives and estimates)
Under the same disk hypothesis, for every ,
The series converges uniformly on every smaller closed disk. The function has derivatives of every order, , and, with ,
Proof
(One geometric series does all the work)
For and , the expansion
converges uniformly and absolutely in both variables. Insert it in (3) and integrate term by term to obtain (4). The contour estimate gives . For , the th derivative terms are bounded by , apart from finitely many initial terms, so each derivative series converges uniformly on . To justify differentiation, choose . The polynomial identity for bounds each difference quotient by when both points lie in the disk. The resulting numerical majorant is summable, so the quotient of the series tends termwise to its derivative. Repeating this argument gives all orders and . Multiplying the coefficient bound by proves (5).
Worked example 5.1.7
(A nearby pole determines the geometric series)
For and ,
The series follows from a geometric expansion. The singularity at is on the boundary, so no larger disk centered at zero can carry this same power series: at its terms do not tend to zero. For , (5) gives the valid, generally nonsharp bound .
Counterexample mode
A derivative at one point is not holomorphy on a disk
The function is complex differentiable at zero with derivative zero, since . Yet on ,
There is no contradiction with (3): is not holomorphic on a neighborhood of the closed disk. Differentiability at the evaluation point alone is insufficient.
The disk formula turns many contour integrals into a single evaluation, provided the point lies inside the circle.
Worked example 5.1.8
(Evaluating a contour integral with the disk formula)
Compute with positive orientation. The function is entire, so it is holomorphic on an open set containing , and satisfies . Formula (3) gives
Edge case: for the point lies outside the circle. The integrand is holomorphic on the open disk , which contains the circle, so the corollary on primitives gives , not .
Common mistake
(Cauchy's formula needs the point inside the circle)
Formula (3) is stated only for . If , the integrand is holomorphic on a disk with (by compactness, is holomorphic on such a disk for small ), so the integral is . On the circle itself, , the integral is in general not even defined.
Worked example 5.1.9
(A coefficient integral and a sharp estimate)
By (4) with , and ,
The estimate (5) cannot be improved in general. For and any , and , so both sides of (5) equal .
Common mistake
(Dropping the factorial)
From (4), . Writing instead gives in the previous example rather than . The derivative form of the formula is .
Practice with solutions
Quick check
(For any triangle , what is ?)
The integrand is entire.
Solution · Answer
Zero. The polynomial is entire, so (1) applies. Directly, is a primitive.
Quick check
(If is holomorphic on a neighborhood of and on , how large can be?)
Use (5) with and .
Solution · Answer
Equation (5) gives . The bound is attained by , which has modulus on and . It concerns the center of this specified disk.
Quick check
(Compute with positive orientation.)
Choose the function in (3).
Solution · Answer
Apply (3) to the constant function at , which lies inside the circle. The integral is .
Quick check
(Why does the corollary on primitives not imply ?)
Check where is holomorphic.
Solution · Answer
The function is holomorphic near the circle but not on any open disk containing the circle, since such a disk contains . Direct parametrization gives . The disk hypothesis cannot be omitted.
Exercise 5.1.10
(Suppose is entire and for constants and . Prove that is constant.)
CoreProof
Solution(3)
- 1
Estimate on a large circle about a fixed point
For , every with has , so and
Because: Equation (5) with .
- 2
Let the radius grow
Key step
and as , so .
Because: makes the numerator grow more slowly than .
- 3
Conclude
∎Since was arbitrary, on the connected set , and is constant.