Read path/homotopy lifting, the circle group and based change-of-point conventions first. Throughout, the base is path-connected and locally path-connected, and coverings are continuous surjections with evenly covered neighborhoods. Existence of a cover for every subgroup is deferred to the next construction; this chapter classifies and compares covers that already exist.
Motivation
A lifted path remembers where it ends, even when its projection returns to its starting point. Loops therefore move points around a fiber. The loops that return one chosen point to itself form the subgroup carried by the covering. This converts a geometric lifting problem into a precise subgroup-inclusion test.
A covering symmetry must respect every such loop motion. Transitivity of loop motion in a connected cover does not imply transitivity of its symmetries: most permutations of a fiber will not commute with the loop action. The normalizer formula will measure exactly which ones do. A three-sheeted graph cover will make this difference concrete.
Definitions
Definition 6.2.1
(Locally path-connected spaces)
A space is locally path-connected if every point has a basis of path-connected open neighborhoods. Its path components are open: a path-connected neighborhood of any point lies in its component. Hence connected locally path-connected spaces are path-connected. A covering of a locally path-connected space inherits this property through its sheet homeomorphisms.
Definition 6.2.2
(Carried subgroup and maps of covers)
Fix and write . For a connected cover , choose and put . Such is path-connected by the preceding observation. A map of covers satisfies ; an equivalence is a homeomorphism of covers. It is based when it preserves the specified points.
Definition 6.2.3
(Deck transformations and the normalizer)
A deck transformation is a homeomorphism with . The group of these maps uses ordinary composition. Its normalizer subgroup is
We concatenate loops by traversing the first factor and then the second. Accordingly the loop action on a fiber will be a right action. Its cosets are written explicitly as , to avoid changing conventions midway through the proofs.
Theorem/proposition
Theorem 6.2.4
(The based map-lifting criterion)
Let be path-connected and locally path-connected, continuous, and . A lift with exists exactly when
When it exists, it is unique. The cover need not be connected for this assertion.
Theorem 6.2.5
(Monodromy, stabilizers and sheet number)
The fiber has a right -action by lifted-loop endpoints. Its orbits correspond to path components of . In a connected cover it is transitive, its stabilizer at is , and
is a bijection. Thus the number of sheets is the subgroup index , including infinite indices.
Theorem 6.2.6
(Subgroups compare existing connected covers)
A based map from to exists precisely when . The based covers are equivalent precisely when . Their unbased covers are equivalent precisely when are conjugate in .
Theorem 6.2.7
(Deck group and regularity)
For a connected cover,
A deck transformation fixing one point is the identity. The deck group acts transitively on a fiber precisely when is normal in ; this property defines a regular covering here.
Concept lensAlgebraic
Deck maps as permutations commuting with monodromy
Restricting to the fiber loses nothing: a deck map is determined by one value, and it commutes with the action of on . Conversely, a permutation of commuting with that action preserves stabilizers, so with ; then agrees with at , hence on the whole transitive fiber. Thus is the centralizer of the monodromy action among the permutations of . The three-sheet graph example below computes exactly this centralizer.
Proof sketch or proof idea
Proof
(Closed lifts and the map-lifting criterion)
First record a consequence of the previous lifting results: a loop at lifts to a loop at exactly when its class lies in . If its lift is closed, that lift itself represents the required class upstairs. Conversely a representative projected from an upstairs loop has a closed lift; homotopy lifting preserves endpoints for every representative of its class.
Necessity of the map-lifting criterion follows from . For sufficiency, choose a path from to and define as the endpoint of the lift of starting at . For another path , the projected loop has class in , so its lift closes. Reverse the second part of that closed lift: it is a lift of starting at and ending where the lifted first part ended. Path-lift uniqueness proves the endpoint independent of .
To check continuity near , choose an evenly covered neighborhood of and a path-connected open neighborhood of inside . For , append to a path in from to . Its image lifts inside the single sheet over containing . Consequently , proving continuity. Any two lifts with the prescribed start agree along every path from , hence everywhere.
Proof
(Monodromy and the coset bijection)
For monodromy, define to be the endpoint of the lift of a loop representing from . Homotopy lifting makes this well-defined. Lifting a concatenation one piece at a time gives ; the identity fixes and the inverse reverses the motion. Two fiber points lie in the same orbit exactly when a path upstairs joins them: project such a path for one implication and use the lifted loop for the other. Every path component meets the fiber, by lifting a base path from its projected point to . This proves the component assertion.
The stabilizer is by the closed-lift observation. Further,
This proves the coset bijection, without assuming normal. The fiber over every other base point has the same cardinality: lift a fixed base path and its reverse to give inverse endpoint bijections.
Proof
(Comparing covers through their subgroups)
For maps between connected covers, apply the lifting criterion to and the cover . If subgroups are equal, lift in both directions; the composites fix the chosen points and lift the same projection, so uniqueness makes them identity maps. Conversely an equivalence and its inverse give equality of subgroups. Moving the chosen point from to changes its stabilizer to
Indeed fixes that point exactly when fixes . Thus forgetting the chosen point replaces equality by conjugacy, proving the last classification statement for existing covers.
Proof
(Deck maps from normalizer elements)
A deck map is determined by its value at one point, by uniqueness applied to lifts of . It also commutes with monodromy: applying it to a lifted loop yields the lift starting at the new point. In particular it preserves stabilizers. If , this requires , or .
Conversely, for such , the map-lifting criterion supplies a lift of sending to , since their carried subgroups agree. Lifting back with the reversed chosen points gives an inverse by uniqueness, so this lift is a deck homeomorphism. Moreover
hence . The kernel is , and every deck map occurs. Since is normal in its normalizer, this proves the quotient formula. All fiber points can be deck images of exactly when every coset has a normalizer representative, equivalent to , or normality of .
Proof X-ray
Where each hypothesis enters the deck-group proof
The proof has two halves that use different tools. Necessity uses only commutation with monodromy: a deck map carries the stabilizer of to the stabilizer of its image, and the change-of-point formula turns this into . Sufficiency is the map-lifting criterion applied to itself, which is where local path-connectedness of , inherited from , enters. Connectedness of is used for uniqueness: it makes invertible and makes multiplicative, because a deck map is determined by one value.
Loop motion acts on the right of for every subgroup. Deck maps act on the left, by , and only normalizer elements make that rule well defined. A transitive loop action therefore need not produce a transitive symmetry group; the graph example below has the first property and a trivial deck group.
Worked examples
Worked example 6.2.8
(Finite and infinite covers of the circle)
For , , , the carried subgroup is , by the earlier degree calculation. The fiber has points and a generator moves to the next root of unity. Every subgroup of is normal, so the deck group is , realized by rotations through multiples of . For , the subgroup is zero and the deck group is , realized by integer translations. The latter fiber is infinite; no finite-sheet assumption was used.
Worked example 6.2.9
(A product cover of the torus)
The map on , , is a cover: products of evenly covered arcs have disjoint rectangular sheets. The product fundamental-group theorem identifies its subgroup with . Thus it has sheets and deck group . A based circle map with winding pair lifts exactly when divides and divides . This applies to every continuous map with those winding numbers, not only to explicit power maps.
Counterexample mode
Equal sheet numbers do not give equivalent covers
Claim: two connected covers of with the same number of sheets are equivalent. On the torus take and . Both total spaces are tori and both covers have two sheets. By the product computation above, their carried subgroups are and . These differ, and in the abelian group conjugate subgroups are equal, so the covers are not equivalent, even without base points. The sheet number records only the index; the repair is to compare the subgroups up to conjugacy.
Worked example 6.2.10
(A connected three-sheet cover with no nonidentity deck map)
Take the figure eight with oriented loop labels . Above its vertex place vertices . For each , attach an oriented -edge from to and a -edge from to , mapping each edge once around its labeled base loop. Each vertex has exactly one incoming and one outgoing half-edge of each label. Small vertex stars, together with edge-interior intervals, verify the evenly covered condition.
The transpositions generate a transitive action on the three vertices, so the cover is connected. A deck permutation must commute with both. Commuting with fixes its unique fixed vertex ; commuting with fixes vertex ; hence it fixes vertex too. The fiber permutation is identity, and connected-cover uniqueness makes the deck map identity. Three sheets do not force three symmetries; its index-three subgroup is not normal.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Normality is not needed for a connected cover)
A subgroup need not be normal for a connected covering to exist or for its fiber to be a coset set. Normality is required for the deck group to move any chosen fiber point to every other one. Quotient-group notation must not be used as a group without that hypothesis.
Common mistake
(A pointwise choice of endpoints is not yet a lift)
The lifting criterion requires a specified lift of the basepoint and local path-connectedness of the domain for the continuity construction. An arbitrary pointwise assignment of endpoints is not a lift until continuity has been checked. Subgroup inclusion also points in a definite direction: a smaller carried subgroup maps to a larger one.
Counterexample mode
Simply connected but not liftable: the Warsaw circle
Claim: for a path-connected domain, the subgroup inclusion alone guarantees a lift. Let be the union of the segment , the oscillating arc and the polygonal arc through , , , . It is compact and path-connected.
No path runs along into : if converged to a point of , the -coordinate would take every small positive value near the limit time, so the second coordinate would keep returning to . By uniform continuity a loop therefore misses some point , and the path component of containing the loop is an arc, which is contractible. Hence , and the inclusion holds for every cover.
Let collapse ; it maps the open arc homeomorphically onto the circle minus one point. Suppose lifted . On the connected set , which maps to one point, it is a constant , because fibers are discrete. Along the open arc it changes by exactly from one end to the other. Continuity at points of forces the limit at both ends: along at , and along , whose points accumulate on . This contradiction shows that no lift exists. The domain fails to be locally path-connected at the points of , which is exactly what the continuity step of the proof required.
Common mistake
(Changing the chosen point conjugates the subgroup)
Finally, a based equivalence remembers the subgroup itself, while an unbased equivalence remembers its conjugacy class. Switching the chosen point without conjugating the subgroup loses information even though the underlying cover has not changed.
Summary
Closed lifted loops detect the carried subgroup and give the map-lifting criterion. Loop endpoints identify a connected fiber with . Inclusion, equality and conjugacy control maps and equivalences of existing covers. Deck symmetries are more restrictive than loop motion and form , with transitivity exactly for normal subgroups.
Exercises
Quick check
(A based map has degree . Determine when it lifts to , and when it lifts to . Does the latter require constant?)
Solution · Answer
The lifting criterion is , or . For the real-line cover its subgroup is zero, so the condition is . It does not require a constant map: for example is nonconstant and has the continuous real lift . Every permitted starting point determines one lift.
Quick check
(Determine when a based torus map inducing the integer matrix on lifts to the product -power cover. State the row-wise divisibility condition.)
Solution · Answer
The image subgroup must lie in . Thus every entry in the first row of is divisible by and every entry in the second row by . These conditions are sufficient as well as necessary. They concern the image of both generators, so checking only one column is insufficient. The lift is unique after its value at the based point is fixed.
Quick check
(If , prove the induced based map of connected covers is itself a surjective covering, and compute its fiber cardinality as .)
Solution · Answer
A path from the chosen point of to any target lifts under after projection; its image under the cover map is the original path by -lift uniqueness, proving surjectivity. Choose a path-connected base neighborhood evenly covered by both projections. Each sheet of maps into one sheet of , because it is path-connected, and there the map is the composition of the two sheet homeomorphisms. Over one sheet of , its preimage is a union of such sheets, so the map is a covering. On the base fiber it sends to . The preimage of consists of the cosets with , giving the stated cardinality.
Quick check
(Prove every connected two-sheet covering under the standing hypotheses is regular. Why does the three-sheet graph example not contradict this?)
Solution · Answer
An index-two subgroup is normal: for , both and are the complement of in , while for they both equal . Thus for every . The deck theorem now gives transitivity, and its group has two elements. Index-three subgroups need not be normal, exactly as the graph cover exhibits.
Quick check
(Show the assertion that a deck map fixing one point is identity fails for disconnected covers, using three disjoint copies of the base.)
Solution · Answer
Let with each component projecting identically. The homeomorphism fixing the first component and swapping the other two commutes with the projection. It fixes every point of the first component but is not identity. Path-lift uniqueness only propagates equality through a path component; connectedness was the hypothesis allowing propagation throughout the earlier total space.