New spaces are built from old ones in two basic ways: by taking coordinates (products) and by gluing points together (quotients). The right topology in each case is the one that makes maps in or out behave as well as possible. This chapter makes that statement precise and proves it.
Motivation
The plane has two descriptions: as pairs of reals with the Euclidean metric, and as the product of two copies of the line. A cylinder, a torus, or a circle can likewise be obtained from simpler pieces, either as a product (circle times interval) or by gluing (a closed interval with its endpoints identified). A satisfactory definition must have the property that a map into a product is continuous exactly when its coordinates are, and that a map out of a glued space is continuous exactly when the corresponding map on the original space respects the gluing and is continuous. Such properties are called universal properties, and they, rather than any formula for the open sets, are what one uses in practice.
For infinite products the box topology is another legitimate topology. It fails the coordinate-wise universal property we seek; understanding that failure is a central part of this chapter.
Definitions
Definition 2.1.1
(Product topology)
Let be topological spaces and with projections . The product topology is the topology generated by the subbasis
A subbasis is any family of subsets; the topology it generates has as a basis the finite intersections of its members (the empty intersection is ). Concretely, a basis for the product topology consists of the sets with open in and for all but finitely many .
Definition 2.1.2
(Box topology)
The box topology on has as basis all sets with each open in , with no restriction on how many differ from . For finite the two topologies coincide; for infinite the box topology is finer and usually strictly so.
Definition 2.1.3
(Quotient map and quotient topology)
A surjection of topological spaces is a quotient map if is open if and only if is open in . If is a space, an equivalence relation, and the canonical surjection, the quotient topology on is the one declaring open exactly when is open; then is a quotient map.
Definition 2.1.4
(Saturated set)
For a surjection , a set is saturated if , equivalently if is a union of fibers .
Definition 2.1.5
(Open map)
A function is open if it sends open sets to open sets.
Concept lensStructural
Coarsest and finest topologies
Both constructions are extremal. The product topology is the coarsest topology on for which every projection is continuous: any such topology contains each , hence everything these sets generate. The quotient topology is the finest topology on for which is continuous: for any such topology, each open has open. The box topology also makes every continuous, but for infinite products it is not the coarsest such topology.
Theorem/proposition
Proposition 2.1.6
(Basis for the product topology)
The sets described above form a basis, and the topology they generate is the product topology.
Proposition 2.1.7
(Universal property of products)
Let be a function. Each projection is continuous, and is continuous in the product topology if and only if every coordinate function is continuous.
Proposition 2.1.8
(Box versus product)
Let . The map , , is continuous in the product topology and not continuous in the box topology.
Proposition 2.1.9
(Universal property of quotients)
Let be a quotient map, a function that is constant on each fiber of , and the unique function with . Then is continuous if and only if is continuous.
Proposition 2.1.10
(Saturated open sets)
A continuous surjection is a quotient map if and only if is open in for every saturated open set . In particular, an open continuous surjection is a quotient map, but a quotient map need not be open.
Proposition 2.1.11
(The circle as a quotient)
Let on identify and and nothing else. Then is homeomorphic to with the subspace topology.
Proof sketch or proof idea
All proofs are given in full.
Proof
(Finite intersections of subbasic sets)
Let be the family of sets with open and for all outside a finite set. Then , so these sets cover . If and lie in then their intersection is , each factor open and equal to outside the union of two finite sets, so it lies in ; this gives the intersection condition for a basis. A set in with only for equals , a finite intersection of subbasic sets; and every finite intersection of subbasic sets has this form, because . So is exactly the family of finite intersections of .
Proof
(Check subbasic preimages)
The preimage of an open is a subbasic open set, so is continuous, and compositions of continuous maps are continuous; this gives the forward direction. Conversely suppose each is continuous. For a subbasic set, is open in . Preimages commute with finite intersections, so of each basic open set is open; and preimages commute with unions, so of each open set (a union of basic sets, since these sets form a basis) is open.
Proof
(A box neighborhood that shrinks to a point)
Each coordinate of is the identity map , which is continuous, so is continuous in the product topology by the universal property of products. In the box topology, is a basic open set containing . Its preimage is , which is not open in .
Proof
(Pull open sets back through the quotient)
Let be open. Then . If is continuous, is open, hence is open and, since is a quotient map, is open; so is continuous. If is continuous then is a composite of continuous maps ( is continuous because open implies open).
Counterexample mode
The universal property needs a quotient map
Claim: if is any continuous surjection and is continuous, then is continuous. Let be with the discrete topology, be with its usual topology, and the identity map; it is continuous because every subset of is open, and it is surjective. Let be with the discrete topology and the identity. Then is the identity between discrete spaces, hence continuous, and it is constant on the fibers of , which are singletons. But is not open in , so is not continuous. The proof breaks at the step “ open implies open”, which is exactly the defining property of a quotient map; this lacks it, since has open preimage but is not open in . The hypothesis that is a quotient map is the repair.
The saturated-set criterion below gives a practical test for that hypothesis.
Proof
(Saturated preimages)
Suppose is a continuous surjection. First assume is a quotient map and let be saturated and open. Then is open, so is open. Conversely assume images of saturated open sets are open, and let with open. The set is saturated, and since is surjective , so is open. Hence is a quotient map. If is continuous, surjective and open, then in particular images of saturated open sets are open, so is a quotient map. That the converse of the last sentence fails is shown by the worked example of a quotient map that is not open.
Proof
(Factor through the quotient, then use compactness)
Let be the canonical map and , . The map is continuous, surjective, and constant on the fibers of (these are and singletons), so for a function , which is continuous by the universal property of quotients. It is bijective because holds exactly when or . The domain is compact, being a continuous image of the compact interval , and is Hausdorff. By the theorem of the next chapter (a continuous bijection from a compact space onto a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism), is a homeomorphism.
Proof X-ray
What each fact does in the circle proof
Three separate facts are combined, and each settles a different question. Constancy of on the fibers of makes well defined; the fact that the fibers of are exactly the fibers of , namely and singletons, makes injective. The universal property of quotients gives continuity of without any computation with open sets of . Continuity of the inverse is the only hard direction, and it is not proved directly: compactness of the domain and Hausdorffness of give it at once. Without compactness this last step fails: on is a continuous bijection onto whose inverse is discontinuous at .
The proof of the circle-as-quotient proposition depends on facts about compactness that are proved in the next chapter; its compactness proofs use the product definition but do not use the circle-as-quotient result, so the theorem dependencies are not circular.
Worked examples
Worked example 2.1.12
( is the Euclidean plane)
A product-basic open set is with open in . If choose with and ; the Euclidean ball lies in the square . So is Euclidean-open. Conversely, a Euclidean ball contains the square , because the corner distance is . So every Euclidean-open set is a union of products of open intervals. The two topologies coincide.
Worked example 2.1.13
(A quotient map that is not open)
With as above, is a quotient map: in the proof of the circle-as-quotient proposition, with a quotient map and a homeomorphism, and a composite of a quotient map with a homeomorphism is again a quotient map. The set is open in , but contains and does not contain for small (which equals with and is not the image of any point in ). Hence is not a neighborhood of , so is not open. Notice that is not saturated: its saturation contains . The open set is saturated and its image is open, as the saturated-set criterion predicts.
Worked example 2.1.14
(A Hausdorff space can have a non-Hausdorff quotient)
Let send negative numbers to , zero to , positive numbers to . A set is open iff is open. If , then is an open set containing , so it contains small positive and negative numbers; hence . The open sets are therefore . The only open set containing is , so cannot be separated from by disjoint open sets. This is an example in which the quotient topology loses the separation property of the original space.
Worked example 2.1.15
(Product versus box, sequences)
In let . A basic product neighborhood of constrains only finitely many coordinates, say those with index at most , to lie in intervals ; for the sequence lies in it, so in the product topology. In the box topology it does not: the neighborhood contains only if for every , which never happens.
Counterexample mode
A quotient map need not preserve every open set
The false claim is that identifying points sends each open set to an open set. For the interval-to-circle quotient, the set is open in the interval but its image includes the seam point without including points approaching from the other side. Its saturation is , which is not open in . The quotient definition therefore makes the image nonopen.
The repaired claim concerns saturated open sets: their preimage after projection is exactly the original set, so the quotient criterion applies. Saturation is the precise way to check that an assertion respects the identifications, rather than just checking representatives separately.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Infinite products are not box products)
The box topology looks like the natural generalization but destroys the universal property: the box-versus-product proposition shows the diagonal map fails to be continuous even though all its coordinates are.
Common mistake
(Quotient maps need not be open or closed)
Quotient maps are only required to have the "preimage open iff open" property. The map above is closed (as a map of compact to Hausdorff) but not open, and other quotient maps are neither.
Common mistake
(Quotients can lose the Hausdorff property)
The non-Hausdorff quotient example shows the failure of the Hausdorff property. Collapsing the negative reals, and the positive reals of to three points gives a quotient in which the only open set containing the image of is the whole space, so that point cannot be separated from either of the others.
- Applying the saturated criterion to non-saturated sets. The images of non-saturated open sets need not be open; compare and .
- Taking the quotient topology to be the subspace topology. A quotient set is not a subset of ; the topology is determined by , not by restriction.
Summary
The product topology is characterized by the property that a map into the product is continuous iff each coordinate is; in infinite products the basic open sets constrain only finitely many coordinates, and on the box topology is strictly finer. A quotient map is a surjection whose open sets are exactly those with open preimage; a map out of a quotient is continuous iff its composite with is. A continuous surjection is a quotient map iff it carries saturated open sets to open sets. The circle is the interval with endpoints identified, a fact established using compactness and the Hausdorff property.
Exercises
Quick check
(Prove that in with the product topology, a sequence converges to if and only if for every .)
Solution · Answer
If , each projection is continuous, so (continuous maps preserve convergent sequences). Conversely suppose every coordinate converges and let be a neighborhood of ; it contains a basic set containing with except for . For each , for . For , .
Quick check
(Show that does not converge to in the box topology on .)
Solution · Answer
The set is a box-open neighborhood of . For each , the coordinate of is , which is not in . Thus for all , so the sequence does not converge to .
Quick check
(Let be a quotient map and a saturated closed set. Prove that is closed in .)
Solution · Answer
The complement is open, and is saturated because the complement of a saturated set is saturated (if and , then , since otherwise ). Also : this holds because and are disjoint by saturation and cover by surjectivity. By the saturated-set criterion, is open, so is closed.
Quick check
(Let and identify with . Show that is open in the quotient but is not.)
Solution · Answer
The set is open and saturated (it contains neither nor ), so the saturated-set criterion gives that is open. The set is open in but not saturated. Its preimage under of its image is , which is not open in (every neighborhood of contains points near that are larger than ). By the definition of the quotient topology, is therefore not open.
Quick check
(Show that the projection is an open map, and that it is not a closed map.)
Solution · Answer
Open: a basic open set has image (when ) or ; images commute with unions, so the image of any open set is a union of open sets. Not closed: is closed in (the preimage of under the continuous function ), but is not closed in .