The real and imaginary parts of a holomorphic function satisfy Laplace's equation, and this is what ties complex analysis to potential theory, steady heat flow and electrostatics. This unit studies real harmonic functions through holomorphic functions. It uses the Cauchy–Riemann equations from Complex differentiation, primitives on disks from Paths, primitives and Goursat, and Cauchy's integral formula and the fact that holomorphic functions are infinitely differentiable from Cauchy's formula and its consequences.
Harmonic functions and conjugates
Definition 10.1.1
(Harmonic function)
Let be open. A real-valued function is harmonic if
Proposition 10.1.2
(Real and imaginary parts are harmonic)
If is holomorphic on , then and are harmonic.
Proof
(Real and imaginary parts of a holomorphic function)
A holomorphic function is infinitely differentiable, so are . The Cauchy–Riemann equations , give and . Since mixed partials of a function agree, . The same argument gives .
Definition 10.1.3
(Harmonic conjugate)
If is harmonic, a harmonic conjugate of on is a real function such that is holomorphic on .
Proposition 10.1.4
(Harmonic conjugates are unique up to a constant)
On a connected open set, two harmonic conjugates of differ by a constant.
Proof
(Difference of two conjugates)
If are conjugates, is holomorphic with zero real part. The Cauchy–Riemann equations for say that the partial derivatives of vanish, so is locally constant, hence constant on a connected set.
Theorem 10.1.5
(Existence of a harmonic conjugate on a disk)
Let be an open disk and harmonic on . Then has a harmonic conjugate on .
Proof
(Build a holomorphic function from the gradient)
Put , and . These are , and because , while . So satisfies the Cauchy–Riemann equations and is holomorphic on . A holomorphic function on a disk has a primitive with . Since , comparing with gives and . Hence has zero gradient on the disk and equals a constant . Then and is a harmonic conjugate.
The hypothesis on the domain is genuine. On the function is harmonic, but it has no harmonic conjugate there: if were holomorphic, then , so would have a primitive on and would be , contradicting the value . (Locally is an argument of , which cannot be chosen continuously around the origin.)
The mean value property
Theorem 10.1.6
(Mean value property)
Let be harmonic on an open set containing the closed disk . Then
Proof
(Cauchy's formula on a circle)
The closed disk lies in a slightly larger open disk on which is harmonic. By the existence theorem, with holomorphic on . Cauchy's integral formula on , with and , gives
Taking real parts proves the claim.
The maximum principle
Theorem 10.1.7
(Maximum principle)
Let be a connected open set and harmonic on . If attains its maximum over at some point, then is constant. The same holds for the minimum (apply the result to ).
Proof
(The maximum set is open and closed)
Let and , nonempty and closed in by continuity. Let and choose with . For , the mean value property gives . The integrand is continuous and at most , and its average is , so it equals for all . Hence on every circle of radius at most about , that is . So is open. A nonempty open and closed subset of a connected set is the whole set.
Proof X-ray
Why the maximum set is open and closed
- Closedness is free: is the preimage of a point under a continuous function.
- The key move turns "maximum at " into a statement about averages. By the mean value property the average of over each small circle about equals . Since on the circle, the nonnegative continuous function has average zero and so vanishes identically. This is where "maximum over all of " is used: it gives on every circle.
- Connectedness closes the argument: a nonempty subset that is both open and closed is the whole set. On a disconnected set the conclusion fails: on one component and on another is harmonic and attains its maximum without being constant.
Corollary 10.1.8
(Extremes are attained on the boundary)
Let be a bounded open set and continuous on and harmonic in . Then and are attained on the boundary .
Proof
(Compactness and the maximum principle)
The continuous function attains its maximum on the compact set . If it is attained at an interior point of a component of , then is constant on by the maximum principle, hence by continuity equal to that value at the boundary points of (nonempty because is bounded), which lie in .
Corollary 10.1.9
(Uniqueness for the Dirichlet problem)
If are continuous on , harmonic in the bounded set , and equal on , then .
Proof
(Subtract two solutions)
Apply the boundary-extremum corollary to , which is harmonic and vanishes on : its maximum and minimum are .
The Poisson integral formula
Theorem 10.1.10
(Poisson integral formula)
Let be harmonic on an open set containing , where is the unit disk. For with ,
Proof
(Subtract the Cauchy formula at the reflected point)
For this is the mean value property, since . Let , , and write with holomorphic on a disk containing . Cauchy's formula on , with , gives . The point lies outside the closed disk, so Cauchy's theorem gives . Subtract. For ,
using (divide numerator and denominator by , and use ). Moreover . This kernel is real, so , and taking real parts gives the formula.
For continuous boundary data the right-hand side is harmonic in , because is the real part of a function holomorphic in and one may differentiate under the integral. It is a standard theorem, not proved here, that it extends continuously to with boundary values . Together with the Dirichlet uniqueness corollary this solves the Dirichlet problem on the disk, with a unique solution.
Concept lensAnalytic
The Poisson integral as damped Fourier series
Since , the formula says that if has Fourier coefficients , then
Going inward to radius multiplies the th frequency by , so high frequencies are damped fastest. This is the same function, now computed frequency by frequency.
Worked examples
Worked example 10.1.11
(Finding a conjugate)
Let . Then and , so is harmonic on . Following the existence theorem, with primitive . Since (indeed ), and the conjugates are , by the uniqueness proposition.
Worked example 10.1.12
(Mean value property)
Let , harmonic since . The average of over is . Direct check: with , we get and , whose average over is .
Worked example 10.1.13
(A Dirichlet problem)
Find the harmonic on , continuous on , with . Since , try . It is harmonic, and on it equals . By the Dirichlet uniqueness corollary it is the solution. At it takes the value . This agrees with the Poisson formula: using , only the and terms contribute, giving , which is at .
Common mistakes and subtle points
Common mistake
(Conjugates may not exist on a domain with a hole)
A harmonic conjugate is unique only up to an additive constant, and on a domain with a hole it may not exist: on is harmonic with no harmonic conjugate. Existence needs a disk, or at least a simply connected domain.
Common mistake
(A product of harmonic functions is not harmonic)
The function is harmonic, but has .
Common mistake
(The Poisson kernel for a disk of radius )
The Poisson formula above is for the unit disk. For radius one replaces by in the kernel and integrates the boundary values on .
Counterexample mode
Dirichlet uniqueness fails on an unbounded domain
Claim: if is continuous on , harmonic in and on , then . Take the unbounded domain and . Then , is continuous on and on the imaginary axis , yet . The proof breaks because a continuous function on the unbounded set need not attain its supremum; boundedness of makes compact.
Exercises
Quick check
(Show that is harmonic on and find a harmonic conjugate.)
Check and write as the real part of a holomorphic function.
Solution · Answer
: , , sum . : . So is harmonic. Since and , we have and . Check: and . Every conjugate is .
Quick check
(Let be a bounded domain and continuous on and harmonic in , with on . Prove .)
Apply the boundary-extremum corollary to and to .
Solution · Answer
and are both continuous on the compact set and harmonic inside. By the boundary-extremum corollary, and over are attained on , where . So and on .
Quick check
(Let . Without integrating, find the average of over the circle .)
Use the mean value property.
Solution · Answer
is harmonic on and the circle has center , radius . By the mean value property the average is .
Quick check
(Find the harmonic function on , continuous on , with boundary values , and compute its value at .)
Look for a harmonic polynomial with the right boundary values.
Solution · Answer
Take . It is harmonic and on , so . By the Dirichlet uniqueness corollary it is the unique solution. At : , , so . (Equivalently .)
Quick check
(Let be harmonic conjugates of the same harmonic function on a disk. Prove is constant, using only the Cauchy–Riemann equations.)
Subtract the Cauchy–Riemann equations for the two conjugates.
Solution · Answer
Let . Then and are holomorphic, so each satisfies the Cauchy–Riemann equations with the same : and . Hence on the disk. A function with zero gradient on a connected open set is constant (integrate along segments), so is constant.