Conformal maps, disk automorphisms and the Schwarz–Pick lemma
Angle preservation of holomorphic maps, the Möbius automorphisms of the unit disk, their classification via Schwarz's lemma, and the Schwarz–Pick inequality.
§7.2Estimated reading time: 15 min
A holomorphic map with nonvanishing derivative behaves locally like a rotation followed by a scaling. This is what makes holomorphic maps the natural tool for transforming a region of the plane into a simpler one while keeping the geometry of curves. The unit disk has a particularly rich supply of such maps. This unit shows that holomorphic maps preserve angles where the derivative is nonzero, constructs the Möbius automorphisms of the unit disk, proves that they are all of the automorphisms by using Schwarz's lemma and rigidity on the disk, and derives the Schwarz–Pick inequality. Möbius maps in general are discussed in the elementary mapping studio. Throughout, D={∣z∣<1}.
Conformal maps
A smooth curve γ:(−ε,ε)→C with γ′(0)=0 has a tangent direction argγ′(0). The angle at z0=γ1(0)=γ2(0) between two such curves is argγ2′(0)−argγ1′(0), defined modulo 2π and including orientation.
Definition 7.2.1
(Conformal at a point)
A function f holomorphic on an open set Ω is called conformal at z0∈Ω if f′(z0)=0.
Theorem 7.2.2
(Conformal maps preserve angles)
If f is holomorphic near z0 and f′(z0)=0, then f preserves angles at z0 (including orientation) and scales all lengths of infinitesimal displacements at z0 by ∣f′(z0)∣.
Proof
(Chain rule on tangent vectors)
For curves γj through z0 with γj′(0)=0, the chain rule gives (f∘γj)′(0)=f′(z0)γj′(0)=0. Hence
When f′(z0)=0 angles are not preserved: if f(z)−f(z0) has a zero of order m at z0, angles at z0 are multiplied by m. For f(z)=z2 at 0, the ray argz=α goes to the ray argw=2α.
Automorphisms of the disk
Definition 7.2.3
(Automorphism of the disk and the maps φa)
An automorphism of D is a bijective holomorphic map D→D whose inverse is holomorphic; Aut(D) denotes the group of them under composition. (A bijective holomorphic map automatically has a holomorphic inverse, but we do not need this: all inverses below are exhibited.) Rotations z↦eiθz are automorphisms. For a∈D define
φa(z)=1−aˉzz−a.
Lemma 7.2.4
(The Möbius self-maps φa of the disk)
For a∈D, φa is holomorphic on a neighborhood of D, and for all z with aˉz=1,
∣1−aˉz∣2−∣z−a∣2=(1−∣a∣2)(1−∣z∣2).
Consequently ∣φa(z)∣<1 iff ∣z∣<1, and ∣φa(z)∣=1 iff ∣z∣=1. Moreover φa∘φ−a=φ−a∘φa=id, so φa∈Aut(D), with φa(a)=0, φa(0)=−a and φa′(a)=1/(1−∣a∣2).
Proof
(Expanding the modulus identity)
The only pole 1/aˉ has modulus larger than 1 (or there is none when a=0). Expanding, ∣1−aˉz∣2=1−2Re(aˉz)+∣a∣2∣z∣2 and ∣z−a∣2=∣z∣2−2Re(aˉz)+∣a∣2; subtracting gives the identity. It shows 1−∣φa(z)∣2=(1−∣a∣2)(1−∣z∣2)/∣1−aˉz∣2, which has the sign of 1−∣z∣2. For the inverse, φ−a(z)=(z+a)/(1+aˉz) and
Replacing a by −a gives the other composition. Finally φa′(z)=(1−aˉz)2(1−aˉz)+aˉ(z−a)=(1−aˉz)21−∣a∣2, which at z=a equals 1/(1−∣a∣2).
In particular φa is conformal everywhere on D since φa′=0, and it moves any chosen point a to the origin.
Theorem 7.2.5
(Classification of disk automorphisms)
Every automorphism of D has the form f(z)=eiθφa(z) with θ∈R and a∈D.
Proof
(Normalize, then squeeze with the inverse)
Let f∈Aut(D) and a=f−1(0)∈D. Put g=f∘φ−a. Then g is an automorphism with g(0)=f(a)=0. Schwarz's lemma applied to g gives ∣g(z)∣≤∣z∣, and applied to g−1 (also a holomorphic self-map of D fixing 0) gives ∣g−1(w)∣≤∣w∣. Taking w=g(z) gives ∣z∣≤∣g(z)∣. So ∣g(z)∣=∣z∣ for all z, and the equality case of Schwarz's lemma gives g(z)=eiθz. Therefore f=g∘φa=eiθφa, because φ−a−1=φa.
Proof X-ray
Squeezing with the inverse
Normalizing: composing with φ−a moves the zero of f to the origin. This is the only place where a enters, and it produces the condition g(0)=0 that Schwarz's lemma requires.
The key move: Schwarz's lemma bounds g only from one side, ∣g(z)∣≤∣z∣. Bijectivity supplies the other side, because g−1 is again a holomorphic self-map of D fixing 0, and applying the lemma to it gives ∣z∣≤∣g(z)∣.
Closing: ∣g(z)∣=∣z∣ at every point is an equality case of Schwarz's lemma, so g is a rotation. Then f=g∘φa=eiθφa.
What breaks without a holomorphic inverse: there is no second inequality, and the lemma alone gives only ∣g(z)∣≤∣z∣, which maps such as z↦z2 satisfy strictly.
An automorphism is determined by f(a)=0 and the single real parameter θ; equivalently by the image of one point and the argument of the derivative there. In particular an automorphism fixing 0 is a rotation, and an automorphism fixing two distinct points of D is the identity.
Counterexample mode
A self-map of the disk that is not an automorphism
Claim: every holomorphic f:D→D with f(0)=0 is a rotation eiθz. Take f(z)=z2. It maps D into itself and fixes 0, but f(21)=f(−21)=41, so it is not injective, and f(21)=41 differs in modulus from ∣eiθ21∣=21 for every θ. The classification needs f to be a bijection of D onto itself: for a general self-map Schwarz's lemma gives only ∣f(z)∣≤∣z∣, and here ∣z∣2<∣z∣ for 0<∣z∣<1.
If equality holds in the first inequality for one z=z0, or in the second for one z0, then f∈Aut(D).
Proof
(Reduce to Schwarz's lemma)
Let w0=f(z0) and h=φw0∘f∘φ−z0. By the φa lemma, h is a holomorphic self-map of D with h(0)=φw0(f(z0))=0. Schwarz's lemma gives ∣h(ζ)∣≤∣ζ∣ and ∣h′(0)∣≤1. Put ζ=φz0(z); then h(ζ)=φw0(f(z)), which is the first inequality. By the chain rule, h′(0)=φw0′(w0)f′(z0)φ−z0′(0). The φa lemma gives φw0′(w0)=1/(1−∣w0∣2) and φ−z0′(0)=1−∣z0∣2, so ∣h′(0)∣≤1 is the second inequality. Equality in either places an equality case in Schwarz's lemma for h, so h is a rotation and f=φw0−1∘h∘φz0 is an automorphism.
The second inequality says that f cannot expand the hyperbolic length element ∣dz∣/(1−∣z∣2).
Worked examples
Worked example 7.2.7
(Conformality of z2)
At z0=1 the curves γ1(t)=1+t and γ2(t)=1+it have tangents 1 and i, a right angle. For f(z)=z2, f′(1)=2, and f∘γ1=(1+t)2, f∘γ2=1−t2+2it have tangents 2 and 2i: still a right angle, with lengths doubled. At z0=0, f′(0)=0: the rays at angles 0 and π/4 map to rays at angles 0 and π/2, so the angle π/4 is doubled.
Worked example 7.2.8
(An automorphism with prescribed data)
Find the automorphism f of D with f(21)=0 and f′(21)>0. By the classification theorem, f=eiθφ1/2. Since φ1/2′(1/2)=1/(1−1/4)=4/3>0, we need eiθ=1, so
f(z)=1−21zz−21=2−z2z−1.
Checks: f(0)=−21, f(1)=1, f(−1)=3−3=−1, and f(21)=0.
Worked example 7.2.9
(Extremal derivative)
Let f:D→D be holomorphic with f(0)=21. By Schwarz–Pick at z0=0, ∣f′(0)∣≤1−∣f(0)∣2=43. Equality is attained by f=φ−1/2(z)=1+21zz+21=2+z2z+1: f(0)=21 and f′(z)=(2+z)22(2+z)−(2z+1)=(2+z)23, so f′(0)=43.
Common mistakes and subtle points
Common mistake
(Conformal does not mean injective, and critical points scale angles)
Conformal means f′(z0)=0; at a critical point angles are multiplied, not preserved (z↦z2 doubles them at 0). Conformal maps need not be globally injective: ez is conformal everywhere but not injective, since e0=e2πi.
Common mistake
(The conjugate in φa)
In the denominator of φa the conjugate aˉ appears. The formula (z−a)/(1−az) is wrong for complex a and does not preserve the disk: for a=i/2 and z=i it gives 1+1/2i/2=3i, of modulus 31 although ∣z∣=1, whereas the correct formula gives 1−1/2i/2=i.
Schwarz's lemma needs f(0)=0; the maps φa are exactly what is used to move a general point to the origin.
Exercises
Quick check
(Show that φa maps the unit circle onto the unit circle for a∈D, and compute φ1/3(0), φ1/3(21) and φ1/3(1).)
Use the identity ∣1−aˉz∣2−∣z−a∣2=(1−∣a∣2)(1−∣z∣2).
Solution · Answer
If ∣z∣=1, the identity of the φa lemma gives ∣z−a∣2=∣1−aˉz∣2, that is ∣φa(z)∣=1. For surjectivity, given w with ∣w∣=1, the point z=φ−a(w) lies on the circle (same argument with −a) and φa(z)=w. With a=31: φ1/3(z)=3−z3z−1, so φ1/3(0)=−31, φ1/3(21)=5/21/2=51, and φ1/3(1)=22=1.
Quick check
(Let f:D→D be holomorphic with f(21)=0. Prove that ∣f(0)∣≤21.)
Apply the first Schwarz–Pick inequality at a suitable point.
Solution · Answer
Apply the first Schwarz–Pick inequality with z0=21, f(z0)=0 and z=0: ∣f(0)∣≤1−21⋅00−21=21.
Quick check
(Show that f(z)=ez is conformal at every point and that the images of the lines x=c and y=c meet at right angles.)
Compute f′ and the images of the two families of lines.
Solution · Answer
f′(z)=ez=0 everywhere, so f is conformal at every point. The line x=c is parametrized by c+it and maps to eceit, the circle ∣w∣=ec. The line y=c is t+ic and maps to eteic, the open ray argw=c. A ray from the origin meets a circle centered at the origin at a right angle, as predicted since the lines x=c and y=c meet at a right angle.
Quick check
(Find all automorphisms of D with f(0)=0 and f(21)=21.)
Use the classification of automorphisms.
Solution · Answer
By the classification theorem and f(0)=0, f=eiθφa with φa(0)=−a, so eiθ⋅(−a)=0 forces a=0 and f(z)=eiθz. Then f(21)=21eiθ=21 gives eiθ=1. The only such automorphism is the identity.