Monotone functions are the simplest class of functions that can be discontinuous, and their discontinuities are completely controlled. This unit proves that a monotone function has one-sided limits everywhere, that its only possible discontinuities are jumps, that there are at most countably many of them, and that a monotone function is continuous exactly when its range has no gaps. It uses the least-upper-bound property, the – definition of limits and continuity, and the intermediate value theorem from Intermediate values, level sets and inverse functions. Throughout, is an interval and .
Definitions
Definition 3.6.1
(Increasing and strictly increasing functions)
The function is increasing if implies , and strictly increasing if implies . Decreasing functions are treated by applying everything below to .
Definition 3.6.2
(One-sided limits)
For an interior point of , the left limit is and the right limit is , when they exist: means that for every there is with whenever . A function is continuous at an interior point exactly when and both exist and are equal to .
Definition 3.6.3
(Jump discontinuity and jump)
We say has a jump discontinuity at if and exist but are not both equal to . Its jump is .
One-sided limits
Theorem 3.6.4
(One-sided limits of an increasing function)
Let be increasing on and let be an interior point of . Then and exist and
Proof
(Supremum and infimum on each side)
The set is nonempty because is interior, and it is bounded above by , so its supremum exists and . Given choose with . For , monotonicity gives , so . Thus . The statement for is proved the same way with the infimum, which is at least .
Corollary 3.6.5
(Continuity and jumps of an increasing function)
An increasing function is continuous at an interior point iff , and otherwise it has a jump discontinuity of jump . In particular, a monotone function has no removable, infinite or oscillating discontinuities in the interior of its interval.
Proof
(Squeezing the value between the limits)
Since , equality of the outer terms forces all three to coincide, which is continuity.
At an endpoint of only one one-sided limit is relevant and the same argument applies. The absence of oscillation is the reason why is not monotone on any interval .
The discontinuities are countable
Theorem 3.6.6
(Countability of the discontinuity set)
The set of points where a monotone function is discontinuous is countable.
Proof
(Counting the jumps of each size)
Let be increasing and first assume . Let be points of at which is discontinuous. By the one-sided limit theorem and monotonicity, , and . Hence
because the intervals are non-overlapping and lie in . Consequently, for each the number of points with jump at least is at most , so it is finite. Every discontinuity in has a positive jump, hence belongs to one of these finite sets, and the union over is countable. Adding the two endpoints keeps the set countable. A general interval is a countable union of compact intervals, and a countable union of countable sets is countable. Decreasing functions follow from .
Proof X-ray
Why finitely many jumps of each size
The key move is not to count all jumps at once but to sort them by size. A set of points at which the jump is at least is finite because the jumps occupy non-overlapping vertical intervals (two of them can share at most an endpoint) inside the bounded range ; a bounded range has room for only boundedly many pieces of length . The non-overlap is exactly where monotonicity is used: holds because the points are ordered. Boundedness of the range is where compactness of is used.
Without the exhaustion by compact intervals the counting step fails. For on there are infinitely many jumps of size , so the finiteness claim is false on the whole line; it holds on each , and the countable union over restores countability. The bound by is what makes each size class finite, and the union over sizes is what makes the whole set countable.
Continuity and the range
Theorem 3.6.7
(Continuity of a monotone function and its range)
Let be monotone on an interval . Then is continuous on if and only if is an interval.
Proof
(A discontinuity leaves a gap)
If is continuous, is an interval by the intermediate value theorem. Conversely let be increasing and discontinuous at some . Suppose first that is interior, so by the corollary above. Pick in . Then . Choose with and . For we have , for we have , and ; so although it lies between and . Thus is not an interval. If is the left endpoint, a discontinuity means and any is missed while lying between and for ; the right endpoint is symmetric.
For a strictly monotone function on an interval this recovers the fact that the inverse of a continuous strictly monotone function is continuous: the inverse is strictly monotone and its range, the original interval, has no gaps.
Counterexample mode
An interval as range does not force continuity without monotonicity
Claim: if is an interval then is continuous. This is false for non-monotone . Let for and . Every is attained: write with (add if needed) and take . So , an interval. Yet is discontinuous at : for we have . The function oscillates, which a monotone function cannot do by the one-sided limit theorem.
Worked examples
Worked example 3.6.8
(The floor function)
is increasing on . At an integer , , , , so there is a jump of size ; elsewhere is locally constant, hence continuous. The discontinuity set is countable. On the interior jumps at total ; the remaining is the jump at the endpoint , where and . This is consistent with the sum bound in the countability proof.
Worked example 3.6.9
(A monotone function discontinuous at every rational)
Enumerate the rationals as and define
The series converges, , and is increasing since a larger includes more terms. At : for the term is missing from , while contains it, so and is discontinuous at with . At an irrational let and choose with . The finitely many numbers differ from , so there is such that none of them lies in . For in that interval, is the sum of over those with between and ; all these have , so . Hence is continuous exactly at the irrationals. This shows that the countable set of discontinuities can be dense.
Worked example 3.6.10
(A gap in the range)
Let on , and on . Then is increasing with , , , a jump of size ; the value lies strictly inside . Its range is , which is not an interval, in agreement with the range criterion; the value , for instance, lies between and but is not attained.
Common mistakes and subtle points
Common mistake
(The value at a jump is not forced)
The value may lie anywhere in , and need not equal either one-sided limit. In the gap example above equals neither nor . A monotone function is therefore not determined by its one-sided limits.
Common mistake
(The jumps need not add up to )
The bound is an inequality because may also increase continuously between the jumps. For on , the only interior jump is at , where and ; its size is , while .
Common mistake
(Countable does not mean sparse)
The discontinuity set of a monotone function can be dense: the rational-discontinuity example above has a jump at every rational number. Countability says only that the points can be listed, not that they are far apart.
Exercises
Quick check
(Find the one-sided limits at of (with ) and state the jump.)
Evaluate on each side of separately.
Solution · Answer
For , and for , , so , , and the jump is . Since equals neither, is discontinuous at .
Quick check
(Let be increasing and bounded on . Prove that and exist.)
Use the infimum for .
Solution · Answer
Let , which exists because is bounded. Given choose with . For monotonicity gives , hence . For use in the same way.
Exercise 3.6.11
(Let be increasing on with , . Prove that at most points of have jump at least .)
CoreProof
Solution(3)
- 1
Take finitely many such points
Suppose are points of , each with jump at least .
- 2
Use the sum bound
Key step
Because: The vertical intervals are non-overlapping and lie in .
- 3
Conclude
∎Hence , so no collection of more than such points exists.
Exercise 3.6.12
(Let be increasing with for every rational . Prove for all .)
CoreProof
Solution(3)
- 1
Sandwich between rationals
Let and choose rationals . By monotonicity .
- 2
Squeeze
Key step
Letting and through rationals gives .
Because: Rationals are dense on both sides of .
- 3
Conclude
∎Therefore .
Exercise 3.6.13
(Let on . Find all discontinuities in with their jumps, and check the sum-of-jumps inequality.)
Core
Solution(3)
- 1
Compute the values on each piece
is on and on ; is on . So takes values on these four pieces, and .
- 2
Read off the jumps
Key step
At the jump is ; at it is ; at it is .
Because: is constant on each piece, so it is continuous inside it.
- 3
Check the inequality
The total of the jumps in is , and . The remaining is the jump at the endpoint , where goes from the left limit to .