This unit works through two problems in detail: a limit on a domain made of two discrete approaches to the origin, and a family of maps controlled by one exponent.
Facts used
Check accumulation in the actual domain first. Then choose between a uniform norm estimate and incompatible output sequences. Separate the function's value at the center from its punctured behavior.
Definition 5.3.1
(Accumulation point and relative-domain limit)
A point is an accumulation point of if every ball centered at contains a point of different from . If so, means that for every there is such that and imply .
Theorem 5.3.2
(Sequential criterion and its consequences)
Let be an accumulation point of . Then the limit equals if and only if every sequence with has . Consequently, two such sequences whose outputs have different limits exclude any finite limit, and a finite limit forces to be bounded near .
The criterion is proved in Relative-domain limits and sequences. Failure for a target means one fixed positive output gap occurs inside every positive input radius. Changing the domain can change the limit, and a path containing no admissible inputs near the point provides no test.
Worked examples
Worked example 5.3.3
(A domain with two discrete approaches)
Let
(a) Verify that the function is well-defined on and that the origin is an accumulation point, and prove that no finite relative-domain limit exists there. (b) Let . Determine the limit through ; after adjoining the origin to and assigning value there, determine exactly which give continuity, and decide whether any assignment makes the function on continuous after adjoining the origin. (c) Prove that every fixed line through the origin meets in at most two points, and explain why straight-line tests cannot establish a limit on this domain.
(a) Every domain point has positive first coordinate, so division by is valid. The two displayed families are disjoint: equality of first coordinates forces the same positive integer index, but their second coordinates then differ. The sequences
both approach the origin, with nonzero terms in . In particular the origin is an accumulation point. But and . If a finite function limit existed, the sequential criterion would force both output limits to equal it. Their distinct values rule this out.
(b) On the function is identically one. For any tolerance, any positive radius works: every admissible output equals one exactly. Thus the relative limit is one. After adjoining the origin, continuity holds exactly when .
For the full domain , no assignment works. The same two punctured input sequences remain, and a center value cannot make their output limits agree. This distinguishes changing a value at the center from removing an entire approaching branch of the domain.
(c) A nonvertical line through the origin has equation . On the first branch its points must satisfy , and since this forces . On the second branch forces . Each condition selects at most one domain point. A vertical line through the origin is and meets no domain point.
Therefore no fixed line has domain points arbitrarily close to the origin. A line with finitely many nonzero admissible points has a positive lower distance to the origin, or contains none. The origin is not an accumulation point of that line's intersection with . Under our definition no relative punctured limit is assigned on that intersection. Calling the line tests “successful” would confuse an empty nearby test with evidence about the actual domain.
Counterexample mode
One branch of the domain does not decide the limit
On the domain above, suppose someone computes the limit along the first branch only and finds for all , then claims . The second branch gives for all , and is a punctured sequence tending to the origin. Hence the outputs and cannot both converge to one finite limit, and the claim is false even though every point of the first branch gives exactly .
Worked example 5.3.4
(A parameter controls the entire output norm)
For real , define on the punctured plane, with ,
(a) Prove the exact identity . (b) Classify every real according to whether a finite limit exists at the origin, with an – proof for every positive case and admissible sequences for each remaining case. (c) Define and determine exactly when the resulting function is continuous there; explain why bounded output norm alone does not settle continuity at the remaining threshold.
(a) The numerator identity is
Since , the angular vector has norm one. Also for every real . Multiplication gives .
(b) If , the candidate limit is zero. For any , choose . Whenever ,
This controls every nearby point.
If , take the two sequences and . Their outputs are respectively and for every index. Both inputs are admissible and approach zero, but their outputs have different limits. Hence no finite function limit exists.
If , the first sequence gives
Its norm tends to infinity because . An output sequence with unbounded norm cannot converge to any finite vector: convergence would eventually put it within distance one of that vector, making its tail bounded. The sequential criterion therefore rules out every finite function limit. The exact classification is .
(c) For the limit equals the assigned center value zero, so the extension is continuous there. For no finite punctured limit exists, so no center value could make it continuous. In particular, at the norm is constantly one, which is bounded; its direction-dependent values still fail to approach a single vector. Boundedness alone is weaker than convergence.
Concept lensGeometric
The output in polar coordinates
With and , the angular vector is , so . The output lies on a circle of radius and turns twice as fast as the input direction. For the circles shrink to the origin, while for every circle of positive radius is swept as varies, which is why no limit exists.
Worked example 5.3.5
(Restricting the domain changes the limit)
Let . Compare its limit at the origin on the whole punctured plane and on the diagonal .
On , for every , and the origin is an accumulation point of , so the relative limit through is . On the whole punctured plane the sequence gives , so by the sequential criterion the plane limit does not exist (it would have to be both and ). The limit depends on the domain, which must be stated.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Reading a bounded output as a limit)
At in the family above, for every input, so the output is bounded, yet it has no limit at the origin because the outputs and occur along two admissible sequences. Boundedness does not imply convergence.
Common mistake
(Testing along paths that contain no domain points)
If a path meets the domain only in finitely many points near the origin, there is no punctured sequence along it, and any test along it is vacuous. A statement that every line gives the same limit is meaningful only when each line contains admissible points arbitrarily close to the origin.
Quick checks
Quick check
(For , what is , and which works for a given ?)
Use .
Solution · Answer
The limit is . Since , the choice gives for .
Quick check
(Is the origin an accumulation point of , and does the sequential criterion say anything there?)
Look for points of other than the origin near the origin.
Solution · Answer
No. The ball of radius about the origin contains no point of other than the origin, so the origin is isolated. There are no punctured sequences, and no punctured limit is assigned.
Quick check
(On with , what value at the origin makes the extended function continuous?)
What is on ?
Solution · Answer
on , so the relative limit at the origin is and continuity requires .