This unit works through two problems in detail: a sequence in with oscillating coordinates, and a limit at a nonzero point of the plane.
Facts used
First compare individual coordinate errors with Euclidean distance. Next expand a function's error around the target point and bound it by that distance. Finish by translating the estimate into the sequential criterion.
Proposition 5.2.1
(Coordinate convergence)
A sequence converges to if and only if each coordinate sequence converges to the corresponding coordinate of .
Theorem 5.2.2
(Sequential criterion for relative-domain limits)
Let be an accumulation point of the domain . Then if and only if for every sequence with .
Both statements are proved in Relative-domain limits and sequences. The following points are used repeatedly.
- A sequence bound must hold for its whole tail.
- A relative-domain limit requires one radius for every nearby admissible input.
- The punctured limit ignores a value assigned at the center; continuity does not.
Worked examples
Worked example 5.2.3
(Oscillation can coexist with convergence)
For positive integers , let
(a) Determine the vector limit and justify it using coordinate convergence. (b) Prove for every , and give an explicit integer that guarantees whenever . (c) Compare with and show using two subsequences why does not converge, despite being bounded.
(a) The first coordinate has magnitude . The second satisfies . The third has magnitude at most . All three tend to zero. Coordinate convergence therefore gives . The oscillations have amplitudes tending to zero.
(b) Squaring the coordinate bounds gives
Choose
This is a positive integer and satisfies . For every , , so the norm is strictly below . The extra one ensures strictness even when the quotient is an integer.
(c) The even-index subsequence tends to and the odd-index subsequence to . If the whole sequence converged, every subsequence would converge to its limit: the same tail condition applies to all sufficiently large subsequence indices. The distinct limits are incompatible. Boundedness controls size but not convergence to one point.
Worked example 5.2.4
(A limit at a nonzero point)
Define on the whole plane
(a) Prove directly that as , supplying an explicit radius for every ; use , and . (b) Deduce a statement for every sequence whose terms differ from , and explain why checking one chosen sequence would not prove the function limit. (c) Change only the value at to seven. State the resulting punctured limit and decide continuity there.
(a) The denominator is always at least one. Expanding around the target gives
Therefore
If , this is at most . Given , take
For the output error is below . Every point is admissible, and the center is an accumulation point of the plane, so this proves the function limit.
(b) Every such input sequence eventually lies within the chosen punctured radius. Thus . Equivalently the sequential criterion applies. A single chosen sequence would establish behavior only on its terms; the function limit demands the conclusion for every admissible approaching sequence.
(c) Changing the center does not change any punctured input, so the limit remains one. The modified function is not continuous there because its assigned value seven differs from that limit. The original function has value one there and is continuous, as the same estimate also proves.
Worked example 5.2.5
(A limit that does not exist at the origin)
Show that has no limit at .
Along the admissible sequence , for every . Along , for every . Both sequences are punctured and tend to the origin, but their outputs have different limits and . By the sequential criterion no common limit exists. The failure is a fixed output gap of inside every positive radius.
Counterexample mode
Every line gives the same limit, yet the function has none
Let for . Along the line with , ; along and it is identically . So every straight sequence has output limit . Along the parabola , however, for every . The sequence is admissible and tends to the origin with outputs constantly . Since the criterion needs every sequence, does not exist at .
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(Bounded oscillation is not convergence)
The sequence is bounded, and two of its coordinates converge, yet it does not converge because the first coordinate alternates between and . Convergence needs every coordinate to converge.
Common mistake
(Forgetting the cap on the radius)
The estimate holds only for . Taking alone would fail for large , so the radius is .
Quick checks
Quick check
(Does converge in ?)
Look at the second coordinate.
Solution · Answer
No. The first coordinate tends to , but the second alternates between and and does not converge, so by coordinate convergence does not converge.
Quick check
(For in the second worked example, what radius works for ?)
Use .
Solution · Answer
. For , .
Quick check
(Along one sequence one finds . Does that prove ?)
Which quantifier is missing?
Solution · Answer
No. The sequential criterion requires the conclusion for every admissible sequence approaching the point; one sequence only rules out failure along its own terms.