From a family to a differential equation
A direction field can describe an entire family of curves at once. For example, each parabola has a different value of , but at a point with its slope is . Thus the parameter disappears: the equation gives the tangent direction of the family at any such point. We can ask for a second family whose curves cross the first at right angles.
Definition 1.4.1
(Orthogonal trajectory)
Let a one-parameter family of curves have, on an open region , exactly one member through each point, with slope there. A curve in is an orthogonal trajectory of the family if, at each of its points, its tangent line is perpendicular to the tangent line of the member through that point.
For two nonvertical tangent lines of slopes and , perpendicularity means . Therefore, where , the required slope is . This is a local construction: eliminate the parameter only where the algebra permits, and interpret horizontal or vertical tangents separately. Dividing by a slope of zero cannot describe a vertical tangent as a finite derivative .
Proposition 1.4.2
(The perpendicular-slope equation)
Suppose is continuous and nowhere zero on an open region . A differentiable graph lying in is an orthogonal trajectory of the family with slope field if and only if
If moreover is continuously differentiable on , exactly one such graph passes through each point of , locally.
Proof
(Compare the two slopes at each point)
At a point the member through it has the nonvertical tangent slope , and the graph has slope . Both tangent lines are nonvertical, so they are perpendicular exactly when ; since this is the displayed equation. Its right-hand side is continuous, and continuously differentiable under the extra hypothesis, so the existence and uniqueness theorem gives one local solution through each point of .
The hypothesis is exactly what excludes horizontal tangents of the original family, where the perpendicular direction is vertical and no finite can describe it.
Concept lensGeometric
Trajectories follow the gradient of the family
If the family is written as level curves with , each member is perpendicular to . The orthogonal trajectories are therefore exactly the curves whose tangent is parallel to :
For take ; then is parallel to , and the equation gives as before. In this form a vertical tangent of a trajectory, where , needs no separate treatment.
Worked examples
Worked example 1.4.3
(A family of parabolas)
Consider . On a region where and , the original slope is , so a perpendicular graph satisfies
Separating and integrating gives , hence
For this is an ellipse, but the differential equation above describes only its arcs on which both coordinates are nonzero. At an intersection on such an arc, the slopes multiply to . Conversely, differentiating the ellipse equation gives the stated perpendicular slope wherever , so the calculation works in both directions locally. The constant is positive for every point in the stated region; the formal value gives only the point , not a trajectory.
The divisions in this calculation excluded the two axes, and each exclusion has a geometric meaning. At the parabolas all pass through the origin and their common tangent there is horizontal; the parameter cannot be recovered from at that point. At a point with , the original member is , also with horizontal tangent, and the ellipse through that point has a vertical tangent. It is not a graph near that point, although it remains a regular curve and the tangents are perpendicular. The singularity of the slope formula does not by itself make the geometric curve singular. At and , no parabola in the original family passes through the point; an ellipse there is a geometric continuation, not an intersection with that family.
Worked example 1.4.4
(Hyperbolas, and a degenerate constant that is a genuine trajectory)
For the family with , differentiation gives , so the slope field is on the region , . The perpendicular-slope equation is
Check: differentiating gives , so , and . For the trajectories are hyperbolas with asymptotes . In contrast with the parabola example, the edge value is admissible: it gives the lines and minus the origin. On the trajectory slope is and the member through has slope , so the lines really are orthogonal trajectories. A degenerate constant must be tested, neither discarded nor accepted automatically.
Common mistake
(Using the negative slope instead of the negative reciprocal)
Replacing by reflects directions; it does not rotate them by a right angle. For the wrong equation gives , and the slope product at an intersection is , which equals only on the lines .
Common mistake
(Taking the reciprocal before eliminating the parameter)
From one has . Writing the trajectory slope as and integrating with held fixed gives , which is wrong: changes from one member to the next, so it changes along the trajectory. The parameter must first be eliminated, , to obtain a slope field that depends only on the point.
Practice
Quick check
(Find orthogonal trajectories of the lines on a region where and . Check the result geometrically and explain what happens at an axis.)
Eliminate first.
Solution · Answer
Elimination gives , so a perpendicular graph satisfies . Integration gives , with on the region. Each circle is centered at the origin and its tangent is perpendicular to its radius, which lies along the relevant line. At a nonzero point of the horizontal axis, the circle has a vertical tangent; the formula for does not cover it. At a nonzero point of the vertical axis the circle has a horizontal tangent and the corresponding radial line is vertical, which is not included in the finite-slope family . The origin is excluded: the circles of positive radius do not pass through it.
Quick check
(Find the orthogonal trajectories of on the region .)
The slope field does not depend on after elimination.
Solution · Answer
Here , so trajectories satisfy , that is and . These are parabolas opening to the left, each defined for . Check: gives , and the slope product is .
Quick check
(Show that every circle is an orthogonal trajectory of the family , at points with , and .)
Eliminate and to get the two slope fields, then multiply them.
Solution · Answer
From , differentiation gives with , so . From , with , so . The product of the two slopes is . The excluded line is where the first family has horizontal tangents.