Motivation
In a quadratic extension, conjugation turns into its reciprocal, so the quotient has norm one. Hilbert's theorem 90 says that this simple construction accounts for every norm-one element in any finite cyclic Galois extension. There is an additive analogue: an element has trace zero exactly when it is a difference between an element and its Galois transform. The two results connect equations inside a field to the action of its automorphism group.
Let be a finite cyclic Galois extension of degree , and let generate its Galois group. Thus , and the fixed field of the whole group is . We use the previously proved formulas
and the linear independence of distinct field embeddings. The results include : then is the identity and both statements reduce to their trivial boundary cases.
The necessary norm condition
If and , then
because the product telescopes and . This proves necessity. Sufficiency is not automatic: knowing that a product of conjugates equals one does not by itself identify a suitable .
Worked example 6.4.1
(A quotient in a quadratic field)
Let and , with . Taking gives
Its norm is . Taking gives the same quotient, because multiplying by a nonzero base-field element changes neither numerator-to-denominator ratio nor the result.
Common mistake
(Norm one is not the same as being fixed)
In , the element has norm one but is not fixed by conjugation. A norm-one condition multiplies conjugates; a fixed-point condition equates an element to each conjugate. These are different requirements.
Multiplicative Hilbert 90
Theorem 6.4.2
(Norm one is a Galois quotient)
For ,
Proof
(A twisted sum and independence of embeddings)
The reverse implication was proved by telescoping. For the forward implication, suppose . Put and, for ,
Thus and . Consider the map
The maps are distinct field embeddings and are linearly independent over . Since , is not the zero map. Choose for which .
Applying to the sum yields
Reindex the terms. The term becomes , and the other terms match the remaining terms of . Hence , or . The use of embedding independence guarantees a nonzero ; choosing without checking can make the sum vanish.
Proof X-ray
Where the norm condition and independence enter
The forward direction looks for a nonzero with , that is, a fixed vector of the twisted operator . The products are built so that ; this recursion makes shift each term of one place along. The hypothesis says exactly that , so the last term wraps around to , and cyclicity is used in the same step: is the identity and the powers of are all the automorphisms. The only remaining danger is that vanishes. Independence of the distinct embeddings rules out , because the coefficient is nonzero; it does not promise that a particular test element works, as the choice for below shows.
Worked example 6.4.3
(A cancellation that needs a different choice)
In , take . The proof's map is . Choosing gives zero, but choosing gives . Then . The theorem promises some suitable , not that every works.
Worked example 6.4.4
(A binary finite-field calculation)
Let where , and let . Since , one computes and . Set . Then
Its norm to is one. In fact every nonzero element of has norm one because the target multiplicative group has only the element one, so every one is such a quotient.
Why the nonzero choice exists
The proof uses linear independence of distinct field embeddings; here is its short argument.
Lemma 6.4.5
(Independence of distinct embeddings)
Let be distinct field embeddings. If satisfy for every , then .
Proof
(A shortest relation cannot exist)
Suppose distinct embeddings have a nontrivial relation for every , with coefficients . Choose such a relation with the fewest nonzero terms. One term is impossible, as evaluating at would make its coefficient zero.
With at least two terms, choose such that . Apply the relation at and subtract times the relation at . The first term disappears, while the second has nonzero coefficient . This gives a nontrivial relation with fewer terms, contradicting minimality. The field need not be finite for this argument. In Hilbert 90 it guarantees that the displayed map is nonzero even when its value at a particular test element vanishes.
How many solutions can there be?
Proposition 6.4.6
(All multiplicative solutions)
If satisfies , then the nonzero solutions are exactly with .
Proof
(Ratios of solutions are fixed)
Every is a solution because . Conversely, if is another solution, equality of the two quotients gives
The fixed field of is , since generates the whole Galois group. Thus . The result is a coset description, not an assertion that the equation has a unique solution.
Worked example 6.4.7
(Rational points on the unit circle)
For rational , set . Then
The resulting rational pair lies on . Conversely, Hilbert 90 writes any rational point of norm one as ; if the real part of is nonzero, scaling by a rational number makes it . If the real part of is zero, the resulting point is . Thus the familiar rational parametrization has one exceptional point, and its field-theoretic derivation also accounts for it.
Norm equations with a prescribed value
Hilbert 90 also describes every solution of a general nonzero norm equation, provided one solution is already known. It does not by itself decide whether the first solution exists.
Proposition 6.4.8
(The fiber of a nonzero norm)
Let and suppose has . Then all with are precisely
If no initial exists, the fiber is empty. The equation has only the solution .
Proof
(Dividing by a known solution)
For every nonzero , the quotient has norm one, so multiplying it by preserves norm . Conversely, if , then . Multiplicative Hilbert 90 writes for some nonzero . Finally multiplication by a nonzero field element is invertible, so its determinant and norm are nonzero; the norm of zero is zero.
Worked example 6.4.9
(A rational circle of radius squared five)
In , has norm five. Every element of norm five is with . If has nonzero real part, scaling it by a nonzero rational number gives for rational . Thus
If has zero real part, the quotient is and gives the remaining point . This parametrizes all rational solutions of , once an initial solution is known. It does not prove that a rational point exists on every equation .
Worked example 6.4.10
(Counting a finite-field fiber)
For and , the norm is surjective on multiplicative groups and its kernel has elements, as proved in the finite-field trace-and-norm chapter. The quotient map has kernel , containing elements. Therefore its image has the same cardinality , agreeing with Hilbert 90. Every nonzero norm fiber has that many elements; the count is a finite-field specialization, while the theorem itself does not assume a finite base field.
Working with the construction
For a cyclic cubic extension, the proof constructs
If , applying cycles the three terms: the last becomes and the others become the second and third terms. Thus every nonzero value of is already a solution of . In a finite field one can test candidate values directly, although an exhaustive search through all field elements may be exponential in a compact field description. The existence proof does not assert a polynomial-time construction under every representation.
Concept lensStructural
Hilbert 90 as a conjugacy of operators
View as a -linear operator on . Iterating gives , so the norm is the scalar that the th power of produces. If denotes multiplication by , then . Hilbert 90 therefore says: the twisted operator is conjugate to by a multiplication operator exactly when , the identity that itself satisfies.
Worked example 6.4.11
(A norm-one element in )
Let with , and let be the cube map, which sends to . The element has norm one. Taking gives
because . The full solution set is : the two elements differ by the nonzero scalars . Direct substitution verifies both and the fixed-field argument proves there are no others.
Worked example 6.4.12
(A norm equation can have no solution)
In , the norm of is for rational . Hence the equation has no solution: a sum of two rational squares cannot be negative. The norm-one theorem is still true, but it cannot provide an initial solution to an arbitrary prescribed norm equation. Once one solution exists, the preceding fiber theorem describes the rest.
The additive analogue
For any ,
because the two sums of conjugates differ only by a cyclic shift. The converse is again true.
Theorem 6.4.13
(Trace zero is a Galois difference)
For ,
If one solution exists, all solutions are with .
Proof
(Rank–nullity for )
The -linear map has kernel equal to the fixed field , which is one-dimensional over itself. Rank–nullity gives . The trace is a nonzero -linear functional because the extension is finite and separable and its trace pairing is nondegenerate. Its kernel also has dimension . Telescoping proves , and equality of dimensions gives equality of these subspaces.
If is a solution, then is another exactly when , or . This proof uses no division by ; it remains valid when the characteristic divides the degree.
Worked example 6.4.14
(An additive equation in characteristic two)
In with , Frobenius sends to . Thus in characteristic two. The two solutions to are and , differing by the two elements of the base field. Although , division by the degree two is impossible; the dimension proof handles the case correctly.
Worked example 6.4.15
(A cubic additive equation)
Return to with . Put . Taking gives . The other solution is , and there are no more because the kernel is . In contrast, is not a possible difference: its trace is in . This obstruction applies to every candidate at once.
For a base element , the trace is . If the characteristic divides , every base element has trace zero and is therefore a Galois difference, despite being fixed by itself. The preimage need not lie in . The example has exactly this behavior. When the characteristic does not divide , a nonzero base element has nonzero trace and cannot be such a difference.
A cohomological interpretation without extra machinery
The formulas have the same structure. The norm-one subgroup is the kernel of the norm homomorphism , and Hilbert 90 identifies it with the image of . The trace-zero subspace is the kernel of the trace map , and the additive theorem identifies it with the image of . These are statements about exact kernels and images. The multiplicative map is a group homomorphism because the field is commutative; the additive map is -linear.
For instance, the norm of the base element is . In characteristic different from two it has norm one when is even, so Hilbert 90 gives a nonzero with . For odd its norm is , and the theorem does not provide such a nonzero quotient. In characteristic two the two signs coincide, so this observation must be interpreted separately in the base field itself.
A cyclic generator matters. If an extension has a noncyclic Galois group, one automorphism need not have as its fixed field, and the one-generator statements above cannot be copied without changing their hypotheses. The broader cohomological formulation for arbitrary groups is outside this unit.
Practice and solutions
Quick check
(Why does equal one?)
Solution · Answer
Its conjugate product telescopes to .
Quick check
(In , give an satisfying .)
Solution · Answer
Take ; the quotient is .
Quick check
(Why can the sum used in the proof of Hilbert 90 be made nonzero?)
Solution · Answer
Distinct embeddings are linearly independent over , so their linear combination with coefficient one on the identity is not the zero map.
Quick check
(If is one multiplicative solution, how are all other solutions obtained?)
Solution · Answer
They are exactly for ; the ratio of two solutions is fixed by .
Quick check
(What is the kernel of the additive map ?)
Solution · Answer
The fixed field of , namely .
Quick check
(Why does the additive proof remain valid when the characteristic divides ?)
Solution · Answer
It uses rank–nullity and the nonzero trace functional, never division by the degree.
Quick check
(In , give the solutions of .)
Solution · Answer
They are and , where .
Quick check
(Does an element of norm one have to belong to the base field?)
Solution · Answer
No. The element has norm one over but is not rational.
Exercise 6.4.16
(If has norm , what condition on characterizes all other elements with norm ?)
Core
Solution(2)
- 1
Compare norms by multiplicativity
For , , so exactly when .
- 2
Apply Hilbert 90 to the ratio
The condition is ; equivalently, for some , so .
Because: The ratio has norm one.
Exercise 6.4.17
(Why can no element of satisfy ?)
Core
Solution(3)
- 1
Compute the trace of
With generating , in .
- 2
Differences have trace zero
Here , and .
Because: The trace is a sum over the cyclic group, so .
- 3
Compare
A solution of would give , contradicting . Hence no solution exists in .