Motivation
A normal subgroup and its quotient describe part of a group, but usually not the whole multiplication. If a complementary subgroup exists, every element has a unique two-part form. Moving the second part past the first introduces a conjugation action, and that action records exactly the correction to direct-product multiplication.
Semidirect products make this correction explicit. They both construct groups from actions and recover groups whose normal subgroups have complements. Combining the construction with Sylow theory gives a complete classification at orders , for distinct primes. We will also examine a normal subgroup with no complement, so the splitting hypothesis cannot disappear into notation.
The general construction permits arbitrary groups. The order- theorem concerns primes and finite groups. We use the Sylow theorems proved in the chapter on actions and Sylow theory. One further named mathematical dependency is the proved cyclicity of the multiplicative group of a prime field, used to prove uniqueness of the nonabelian isomorphism type; this link is not a school-prerequisite assertion.
Definitions
Definition 10.1.1
(An action by automorphisms and its external product)
Let be groups and a homomorphism. On the set , define
This group is the external semidirect product , after the group laws are verified below. The action need not be faithful: distinct elements of may induce the same automorphism.
Definition 10.1.2
(Internal complements and split extensions)
For , a complement is a subgroup with and . In that situation is an internal semidirect product of by .
An exact group sequence splits if there is a group homomorphism with . A set-theoretic choice of coset representatives is not enough: multiplicativity of the section is essential.
In a complement decomposition, the map is injective by the intersection condition and onto by . Thus the complement is isomorphic to the quotient. This does not assert that every normal subgroup admits such a complement, or that a splitting makes the action trivial.
Theorems
Theorem 10.1.3
(Construction, recognition, and splitting)
The external multiplication is associative, has identity , and inverse
Its embedded copy of is normal and its embedded copy of is a complement. Conversely an internal decomposition gives an isomorphism , , with .
A group extension splits exactly when its kernel has a complement. For a specified decomposition, direct-product multiplication occurs exactly when the conjugation action is trivial; equivalently both complementary subgroups are normal.
Theorem 10.1.4
(Complete classification at order )
Let be primes. If , every group of order is cyclic. If , there are exactly two isomorphism types: the cyclic group and one nonabelian semidirect product by .
The nonabelian type has presentation
where has multiplicative order modulo . Different such choices of yield isomorphic groups. The theorem does not classify all prime-power orders or arbitrary products of several primes.
Proof sketch or proof idea
The action identity is exactly associativity
Proof
(Associativity, normal form and recognition)
For three pairs, left-associated multiplication gives first coordinate and second coordinate . Right association gives and the same second coordinate. These agree because is an automorphism and . The identity and displayed inverse follow by direct substitution on both sides; the action of undoes that of .
The pairs form a copy of . Conjugating one by gives , proving normality. The pairs form a copy of , with trivial intersection with the first copy, and every pair factors as . This proves the external group has the required internal structure.
For an internal complement, normality makes conjugation by an automorphism of and gives a homomorphism into its automorphism group. Multiplication in satisfies
exactly the external formula. Every element is . If , then lies in the intersection, so both coordinates agree. Thus the multiplication map is a bijective homomorphism. Unique normal form, rather than a bare order count, proves recognition even for infinite groups.
A section is the missing complement
Proof
(Sections, complements and trivial actions)
A homomorphic section has injective image . Its intersection with the kernel is trivial because is identity. Given , put ; then , so . Conversely a complement maps isomorphically to , and the inverse of that restriction is a homomorphic section.
If the action is trivial, the multiplication formula is the direct product and both copies are normal. Conversely, if are both normal, each commutator belongs to both subgroups, hence is one. They commute and the action is trivial. Normality of just was already part of the general construction; it alone says nothing about triviality of the action.
Proof X-ray
Normal form separates existence from multiplication
The complement conditions first give unique coordinates. Conjugation then specifies how those coordinates multiply when a second-coordinate element crosses a first-coordinate element. A section supplies the complement, while associativity is encoded in the homomorphism law of the action. An arbitrary coset transversal supplies coordinates only as a set; its failure to be a subgroup leaves additional extension data.
Sylow theory supplies a complement at order pq
Proof
(Sylow counting and the automorphisms of )
Let . The number of Sylow -subgroups divides and is one modulo . Since , it is one. Thus the unique subgroup of order is normal and cyclic. A Sylow -subgroup is cyclic of order ; its intersection with is trivial because its order divides both primes. The product has elements, so is . Hence every such group is a semidirect product.
An automorphism of sends a generator to , where is a nonzero residue modulo . Composition multiplies those residues, giving . The named prime-field theorem makes this a cyclic group of order . The image of the action of has order one or . If , only the trivial image is possible. Then by coprime cyclic orders.
If , the cyclic automorphism group has a unique subgroup of order . A nontrivial action sends a generator of to an element of exactly that order. Such elements all generate that same subgroup, and replacing the generator by a suitable nonzero power replaces by any other generator of the subgroup. Thus all nontrivial actions give the same isomorphism type. The external construction proves existence, and its nontrivial conjugation proves noncommutativity, distinguishing it from the cyclic type.
Finally, the displayed presentation really presents that external group. Its relation reduces every word to , with modulo and modulo , so the presented group has at most elements. Mapping the generators to the external group is onto a group of exactly that order. It is therefore an isomorphism. This order argument certifies a presentation only after the external multiplication has established a group of the required size.
Concept lensAlgebraic
The nonabelian order-pq group as affine maps of a line
Let be the subgroup of order . The maps on , with and , form a group of order : composition gives . This is exactly the external rule with under addition, and . Translations form the normal , and the maps fixing form a complement. For order twenty-one, and on satisfy , so .
The derived subgroup records the nontrivial action
Proposition 10.1.5
(Commutator subgroup of a product of abelian groups)
Let with abelian, and let be generated by the displacements for , . Then .
Proof
(Displacements are commutators, and they suffice)
Suppose both and are abelian. Inside , let be generated by all elements . Every such generator is the commutator in the internal product, so . The subgroup is normal: conjugation by is trivial on it, and applying to a generator gives , another generator, because the acting group is abelian.
In , the action has become trivial by definition. Both surviving coordinate groups are abelian and commute with one another, so the quotient is abelian. The largest-abelian-quotient property from the first chapter on groups therefore gives . Thus the commutator subgroup is exactly this subgroup of action displacements.
For the nonabelian order- type, one displacement is . Since has prime order, it generates all of . Consequently , and . Its next derived subgroup is trivial because is cyclic. This computes the derived series, not just solvability, and connects the explicit multiplication law to the earlier abstract commutator construction.
Worked examples
Worked example 10.1.6
(Dihedral multiplication is an inversion action)
For , take , and let act by inversion. This is an automorphism whose square is identity, so it defines the order- dihedral group. Each element is uniquely , , and . Every reflection squares to one: . For , the choices , give . At inversion is trivial, so the same construction gives , illustrating why the nonabelian dihedral discussion uses .
Worked example 10.1.7
(The nonabelian group of order twenty-one)
Here , and two has order three modulo seven. Use . The pair formula gives , while the reverse product is . Every element outside has order three: cubing gives exponent , and cubing uses the same sum in a different order. Thus fourteen nonidentity elements have order three, giving seven Sylow three-subgroups, since each contains two such elements. The seven complements agree with Sylow conjugacy. The classification proves this is the only nonabelian order-twenty-one type, rather than merely one constructed example.
Worked example 10.1.8
(A normal subgroup can lack a complement)
In with generator , take , with quotient . The only subgroup of order two is itself, so no complement exists. Equivalently, a lift of the nonidentity quotient element is or , both of order four, so neither can be the image of a generator under a section from . All actions of on are trivial, and their semidirect product is the Klein four group, not . Both groups have the same composition factors; the split versus nonsplit extension distinguishes their assembly.
Counterexample mode
An action need not be faithful
A generator of may act on by inversion. The action homomorphism has a kernel of order two, but the external construction still gives a valid group of order twenty. Its complement has elements of order four; the action image has only order two. Confusing the acting subgroup with its image would produce a group of the wrong order. The homomorphism condition is required, while injectivity is an additional property only when explicitly requested.
Common mistakes
Common mistake
(A normal subgroup need not have a complement)
A normal subgroup need not have a complement. Even when a complement exists, the product is direct only for a trivial action. A set of coset representatives need not be a subgroup or define a homomorphic section.
Common mistake
(Normalize action formulas before classifying)
The order- classification uses distinct primes with . Sylow theory supplies a complement there, but that argument is not a proof of splitting for every normal subgroup of an arbitrary finite group. Different action formulas can describe isomorphic groups after changing generators; a formula list must be normalized before it becomes an isomorphism classification.
Summary
An automorphism action defines associative semidirect multiplication, and an internal complement recovers that construction through unique coordinates. Complements are equivalent to split group extensions. Sylow theory forces such a complement at order , and the cyclic automorphism group of leaves exactly the stated cyclic and possible nonabelian types.
Exercises
Quick check
(If are abelian, prove the center of consists exactly of the pairs with fixed by every element of and .)
Solution · Answer
Commuting with every forces because is abelian. Commuting it with every forces , with no second-coordinate obstruction since is abelian. These two embedded subgroups generate the whole product, so the conditions are also sufficient. Thus the center is as a subset and subgroup of the pair product.
Quick check
(Classify groups of orders thirty-five and fifty-five. For every nonabelian type give an explicit order-certified action.)
Solution · Answer
For thirty-five, and five does not divide six, so only occurs. For fifty-five, five divides ten, so there are and one nonabelian -by- type. Three has order five modulo eleven: its successive powers are , none earlier one. Thus , gives the nonabelian type, with exact size fifty-five by the external construction.
Quick check
(Determine the center of the order- dihedral group for , using the action rather than listing all multiplication cases.)
Solution · Answer
Inversion fixes exactly rotations with . The action of is faithful for , so the center has no reflection coordinate by the first solution. For odd it is trivial; for even it is .
Quick check
(In with inversion action, compute the center and its quotient. Show this group is not the order-twenty dihedral group.)
Solution · Answer
The inversion-fixed subgroup of is trivial, and the action kernel in is . Hence the center is that order-two subgroup. Quotienting reduces the acting complement to and gives the order-ten dihedral group. The original group has an element of order four, whereas the order-twenty dihedral group has rotations of orders dividing ten and reflections of order two, so has no element of order four. They cannot be isomorphic.