A quotient remembers two values
Work over , where , and put
Write for the class of . Because vanishes at both 1 and , changing a polynomial by a multiple of does not change either value. Thus the map
is well-defined. Evaluation respects sums, products and the identity, so is a ring homomorphism, with coordinatewise operations on the product.
Proposition 4.1.1
(Evaluation at and splits the quotient)
The map , , is a ring isomorphism. Its inverse sends to the class of .
Prove the map is an isomorphism
Proof
(Kernel zero by division; explicit inverse by interpolation)
Every class has a unique representative of degree less than 2 by polynomial division. If evaluates to zero at both points, then and . Adding and subtracting gives ; 2 is invertible in , so . Hence the kernel is zero and is injective.
For a prescribed pair , define
Here in . Substitution gives and , proving surjectivity and giving an explicit inverse. Thus .
Proof X-ray
Three places where the setting is used
The proof leans on the setting at three points. Well-definedness: if , then and , so evaluation can be treated as a function of the class and not only of a polynomial. Injectivity: the two conditions and determine only because 2 is invertible, which is also the statement that the two roots and are different. Surjectivity: the formula for divides by 2 again, and having degree at most 1 it is a legitimate representative of a class of . The argument closes without any counting: injectivity together with an explicit right inverse gives a bijection. This is a concrete instance of the Chinese remainder principle; the proof needs only division and direct evaluation.
A worked reconstruction
Worked example 4.1.2
(Idempotents from reconstruction)
Take the desired pair . The formula yields , since and . For , it gives
For it gives . Their classes satisfy , , and in . One way to verify all four claims is to evaluate at 1 and : their images are and , and injectivity transfers coordinatewise identities back to . Directly, in , using .
What the product reveals
Neither nor is zero: each is a nonzero polynomial of degree 1, while a nonzero multiple of has degree at least 2. Yet their product is zero in . Therefore has zero divisors and is not a field. In the product these classes map to and respectively, making their coordinatewise product visibly zero. This is the general mechanism: is a field exactly when is irreducible over , and a factorization into factors of positive degree gives the nonzero classes and with product zero. The reducible modulus is exactly what splits this ring into two copies of .
Worked example 4.1.3
(Units and zero divisors of the quotient)
A class is invertible exactly when both coordinates of its image are nonzero, so the units correspond to with . Reconstructing these four pairs gives the units : indeed , , and . The four nonzero pairs with exactly one zero coordinate, , give the nonzero zero divisors . Together with these account for all nine elements. As a check, in , and is in the list.
Common mistake
(A class that vanishes at one point is not zero)
Because vanishes at , it is tempting to call it zero in . A class is zero only when every evaluation vanishes, that is, when sends it to . Here , so , and it is precisely such nonzero classes with a zero coordinate that multiply to zero.
Counterexample mode
The field and the distinct roots matter
Claim: the same map is an isomorphism for . Over , and , so both evaluations repeat the same value and . The class is nonzero, since it has degree 1, yet , so is not injective. The pair is not in the image, so is not onto. Dividing by 2 in the reconstruction is also impossible there. The distinct-root hypothesis cannot be silently transferred across fields. Moreover in this ring, so it has a nonzero element whose square vanishes, something that never happens in a product of fields.
Exercises and solutions
Quick check
(Find the pair .)
Evaluate at and at .
Solution · Answer
.
Quick check
(Reconstruct the class corresponding to the pair .)
Use with .
Solution · Answer
Here , so , and . The class is .
Quick check
(Is invertible in ?)
Compute .
Solution · Answer
Yes. because , so is its own inverse.
Quick check
(How many elements does have?)
Count the unique representatives of degree less than 2.
Solution · Answer
Nine: the unique representatives have three choices for each coefficient, equivalently the product has pairs.