The same state in better local bases
A bipartite state can have many terms in the computational basis. Some of those terms reflect an arbitrary choice of coordinates; others represent correlations that cannot be removed by changing bases separately on the two subsystems. The Schmidt decomposition identifies the latter for a pure state.
Let and be finite-dimensional complex Hilbert spaces, and let be a unit vector in .
Definition 1.3.1
(Product and entangled pure states)
The state is a product state if for unit vectors ; otherwise it is entangled. Global phase does not affect this distinction.
Theorem 1.3.2
(Schmidt decomposition)
There are orthonormal sets in and in , and positive numbers , such that
The multiset of positive coefficients is uniquely determined by the state, though the bases need not be unique when coefficients repeat.
Definition 1.3.3
(Schmidt coefficients and Schmidt rank)
The numbers are the Schmidt coefficients of , and their number is the Schmidt rank.
Proof
(Singular-value decomposition of the coefficient matrix)
Choose orthonormal bases and and write . Take the compact singular-value decomposition , retaining exactly the positive singular values and orthonormal columns of . If and are matrix entries, define
The second set is orthonormal because conjugating both vectors preserves the Kronecker inner products. Substituting gives the displayed decomposition. Orthonormality of the tensor products and give .
Taking the partial trace of gives
Thus both reduced states have the same nonzero eigenvalues, including multiplicities. Eigenvalue uniqueness proves uniqueness of the coefficients . The conjugation in the definition of matters: a transpose and an adjoint are not interchangeable over complex numbers.
Proof X-ray
Singular values become reduced-state probabilities
The coefficient matrix uses one index for each subsystem, and the one non-obvious move is to read the joint vector as that matrix, so that the singular-value decomposition applies. It makes the joint vector a sum of matched orthogonal terms: orthonormal columns of on one side and of on the other. Two facts then do all the work. The orthonormality of the makes the cross terms vanish when the partial trace is taken over , so only the weights survive; the same holds with the roles swapped. This is why both subsystems see the same nonzero spectrum for a pure joint state. The argument needs the joint state to be pure and the positive singular values to be counted exactly, so that is the rank of . For a mixed joint state there is no coefficient matrix, and the two reduced spectra need not agree.
Common mistake
(Schmidt coefficients are not the reduced-state eigenvalues)
The eigenvalues of are the squares , not the coefficients . For the Schmidt coefficients are and , and only the squares add to one: , whereas .
Common mistake
(Schmidt vectors need not be unique)
Only the multiset of coefficients is unique. When a coefficient repeats, the Schmidt bases can be rotated. For example , because . Both expansions have coefficients but different Schmidt vectors.
Product states, purity and local changes
Proposition 1.3.4
(Product states and Schmidt rank)
A pure bipartite state is a product exactly when its Schmidt rank is one. Equivalently, the reduced state is pure: exactly when one is one and all others vanish.
Proof
(Rank one means a product)
If the Schmidt rank is one, the Schmidt sum has a single term with , which is a product. Conversely, a product expansion has a rank-one coefficient matrix , so its singular-value decomposition has one positive singular value. For purity, with forces a single nonzero term: if at least two positive weights sum to one, their squared sum is strictly below one.
Proposition 1.3.5
(Local unitary equivalence)
A local unitary preserves the Schmidt coefficients. Conversely, two pure states on the same bipartite spaces with the same positive Schmidt coefficients are related by a local unitary.
Proof
(Moving Schmidt sets)
A local unitary sends each orthonormal Schmidt set to another orthonormal set and leaves the coefficients unchanged. Therefore local unitary changes cannot turn an entangled pure state into a product state. Conversely, map one pair of Schmidt sets to the other and extend each orthonormal set to a basis; this defines unitaries carrying one state to the other.
Worked example 1.3.6
(Coefficients of a state with a phase)
For , absorb into the second local vector . The Schmidt coefficients are and . Hence and . The state is entangled, but its coefficients differ from those of a Bell state, so local unitaries alone cannot turn it into one.
Worked example 1.3.7
(A four-term state with two Schmidt terms)
Let . Its coefficient matrix is , where is the Hadamard matrix, and . So both singular values equal , the Schmidt rank is , and the state is maximally entangled. Taking , , gives
Expanding, recovers the four terms.
Worked example 1.3.8
(A product state hidden in four terms)
The state has , whose second row equals its first. So has rank one, with the single singular value because . The Schmidt rank is one, and indeed the state equals . Having many nonzero terms in a basis says nothing by itself about entanglement.
Same local state, different correlations. The Bell states and both have reduced state on either qubit. Yet their joint computational-basis outcomes are respectively equal and opposite. A reduced state determines local measurement statistics, not the full joint correlations.
Counterexample mode
Equal marginals can hide different joint states
The joint mixed state has the same local reduced states as , but it is a classical mixture of product states. The pure-state Schmidt-rank criterion cannot be applied to this mixed joint state. Indeed differs from the Bell projector in its missing off-diagonal terms.
Practice and solutions
Quick check
(Find the Schmidt coefficients and rank of .)
Try to factor the state as a tensor product.
Solution · Answer
Factor it as ; its sole Schmidt coefficient is and its rank is one.
Quick check
(Compute the reduced state and purity for .)
The state is already in Schmidt form.
Solution · Answer
The reduced state is and its purity is .
Quick check
(Can a local unitary map to ?)
Compare the Schmidt coefficients.
Solution · Answer
No. Its squared coefficients are rather than , and local unitaries preserve them.
Quick check
(For the coefficient matrix , find the nonzero eigenvalues of and .)
Find the singular values of .
Solution · Answer
The singular values of are both , so both reduced states have eigenvalues . The phase changes Schmidt vectors but not coefficients.